A Foucauldian Engagement with the “Problem of Ethics” in the Canadian HIV Community-based Research Movement
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation examines the Canadian HIV community-based research (CBR) movement, with an attention to how research ethics is understood and practiced. HIV CBR brings together health researchers, clinicians, service providers, and people living with HIV (PHAs) to undertake collaborative research and evaluation. HIV CBR is characterized by inclusive and community-driven research processes, a commitment to partnership building, and the involvement of relevant stakeholders. However, HIV CBR practitioners claim the formal research ethics review process is unresponsive and alienating, and fails to address the ethical issues present in their work. For these reasons, research ethics review has been identified as a major barrier to HIV CBR. Towards examining these claims, interview data were collected from recipients of Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) HIV CBR operating grants from across Canada. The analysis offered here departs from the majority of the literature by using Michel Foucault’s approach to ethics. Foucault’s work considers the role of power, discourse, and how conceptions of morality emerge within particular systems of governance. This dissertation includes an introductory chapter, three core chapters written in a manuscript format and a concluding chapter. In Chapter 1, I situate my dissertation at the intersections of HIV CBR, empirical bioethics, and critical public health. Chapter 2 examines the confessional dimensions of interviewing participants about their ethical transgressions. Chapter 3 offers an analysis of the relationship between actors in the CBR movement, related funding programs, and the state. Chapter 4 examines the relationship between actors in the CBR movement and prescriptive research ethics. In Chapter 5, I conclude by exploring the implications for advancing greater critical reflexivity in HIV CBR. Overall, this dissertation theorizes the so called “problem of ethics” in HIV CBR and uses it as opportunity to ask different kinds of questions about community engagement in collaborative research.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Adrian Guţă
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2565110560
