Year: 1974
Type: article
Abstract: COMMENT Flight to New Pigeonholes: Comments on Fredrickson THOMAS F. KING In the first issue of this journal, David Fredrickson has put forth a new synthetic scheme for Central Cahfomia prehistory. It is not my purpose to dispute tliis scheme in toto. I am in agreement with Fredrickson that in Central Cahfornia substantial temporal and areal diversity is expressed in the archaeologi- cal record, and that this diversity presents us with an unusual opportunity for the study of human adaptation. I welcome Fredrickson's attempt to re-sort the Central Cahfornia chrono-cultural cards to form new and hope- fuUy more playable hands. The idea of pat- terns as loose complexes of artifacts and attributes that generally express temporal unity and social interconnectedness is valu- able, because it frees our thinking from the semantic binds attached to the old unilineal three-horizon system. We have all disparaged the Grand System for some time; I applaud Fredrickson's initiative in developing a viable alternative for organizing the archaeological record. On the other hand, I believe Fredrickson's paper to be, in some respects, poorly thought out, and I think it is important to introduce some critical comments. After presenting a straiglitforward sum- mary of North Coast Range and Central Cahfornia prehistory as he sees it, utilizing his pattern concept, Fredrickson (1974a:46) opines that: Some kind of integrative framework to encompass this diversity would be useful. 1 propose that the dating and identification of temporal periods in California prehistory be kept separate from the dating and definition of particular patterns and suggest the follow- ing framework . . . . The framework then proposed for the ordering of temporal periods is an apparent adaptation of Wihey and Phillips' (1958) treatment of North American prehistory, sub- dividing their Archaic into Lower, Mid- dle, and Upper, and proposing the Emer- gent as a non-agricultural equivalent of their Formative, a period of political differentia- tion, sedentism, and liigh population. My criticism of this integrative scheme is that I think it is less useful than it is obfuscatory, that it is neither demonstrated in fact nor of hypothetical value. A scheme like Fredrickson's is nothing more nor less than a typology (cf., Willey and Phillips 1958:15-18), in this case, a typology of archaeo-cultural patterns. As such, in standard practice, it must meet at least one of two criteria. First, it may be real, i.e., it may really exist in nature, or have historical reahty (cf., Spaulding 1953; Rouse 1960). Alternatively, it may be arbitrary but useful as an heuristic or analytic device (cf.. Ford 1954). I do not believe that Fredrickson's classification meets either of these criteria. At the risk of erecting straw men, I will examine Fredrickson's scheme in terms of both these criteria. I have alluded to the
Author: Thomas F. King
Language: English
Subfield: Archeology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W256832184
