Work

The European Union Peacebuilding Approach: Governance and Practices of the Instrument for Stability

Year: 2011
Type: article
Abstract: Liberal peace represents a dominant paradigm of contemporary peacebuilding based on the principles of democratization and marketization.This approach is sustained by the assumption that states with strong political democratic institutions, which ensure political representation and a market economy, guarantee sustainable economic growth and provide basic public goods, are necessary conditions for establishing durable peace.Within this dominant approach, scholars have distinguished several gradations that place their emphasis on specific aspects.Therefore, several models can be distinguished within the liberal peace paradigm, in particular, the conservative, the orthodox and the emancipatory models, which prioritize, respectively, institutions of government and rule of law, democratic liberal governance, and welfare and social justice.Within this paradigm the EU stance on peacebuilding and conflict management policy is difficult to categorize.The current EU peacebuilding approach is the result of evolving policy practices and not of a preconceived general policy.As a reaction to the international debates on peacebuilding, the EU adopted a mosaic of disperse documents on specific priorities that later were progressively incorporated into EU activities.At the same time, there is rather limited discussion of the very principles and objectives of the EU peacebuilding approach.Therefore, in order to discuss these questions and to assess EU peacebuilding policy, this report focuses on EU practices for dealing with conflict prevention and peacebuilding.Specifically, the report assesses, in the light of liberal peace modalities, the main patterns of EU peacebuilding practices pursued in the framework of the Instrument for Stability (IfS).This instrument was conceived as the Commission's response to the demands of the greater EU's involvement in conflict prevention and peacebuilding activities.With a budget of € 2 billion for the 2007-2013 period, the IfS permits the EU's engagement in crisis and conflict response as well as in tackling structural sources of security risk and threats throughout the world.After four years of implementation, the IfS provides a very comprehensive view of the broad range of EU practices in the field of peacebuilding and crisis response.The framing of the IfS measures as well as the particular measures analyzed in this report reflect the EU consensus on conservative and orthodox models of liberal peace, emphasizing fundamental security challenges in post-conflict situations and the building of law and order institutions as well as political and economic problems and democratic governance institutions.There are very few measures of an emancipatory version of liberal peace characterized by transcendence of identity and sovereignty problems through contextual legitimacy and respect for local cultures.However, in view of the frequent failure of more traditional approaches to peacebuilding efforts and the planned renegotiation of the Instrument for Stability for the period 2014 to 2020, the report concludes that some proposals deriving from this variant of liberal peace should be seriously considered as a valid alternative or at least a supplement to existing EU approaches.The report begins by introducing the central debates about liberal peacebuilding consensus and setting out the analytical criteria framing the assessment of current IfS peacebuilding practices.The third section of the report describes the main functional II characteristics of the Instrument for Stability, indicating the apparent consensus concerning a broad and comprehensive approach to peacebuilding.The fourth section analyses the governance practices observed during implementation of the IfS.The fifth section assesses qualitatively the use of the different tools offered by the Instrument for Stability, pointing out the main patterns of EU peacebuilding practices in light of various models of liberal peace practices.The sixth section presents the particular challenge of ensuring the appropriate institutional structures for the IfS within the European External Action Service.And finally, the last section concludes and sketches out various scenarios of the role of the IfS in the EU's peacebuilding and conflict prevention policy.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2577284465
FWCI: 1.211
Cites: 13
Cited by: 20
Related to: 10