Work

The Mutual Dependence of Risk Research and Political Context

Year: 1986
Type: article
Abstract: If social studies of science are right in claiming that social and political contexts influence not only the rate and direction of scientific developments, but also dominant problem definitions and the interpretation of research results, it must be impossible for science to deliver fully independent scientific advice to the policy process. This will especially be the case when the science is uncertain and/or geared toward decision making. Still, political demands for independent advice have not decreased, and the need seems to be most urgent in areas of public and regulatory science, where uncertainties, as well as possible sociopolitical influence are the greatest.1 The threat of circularity can be countered in different ways. Besides dogmatic assurances that science is, by its nature alone, objective and independent of context, solutions have been offered of an institutional or procedural nature. Independence is created and maintained by separating scientific assessments from socio-political assessments procedurally, for instance in science court proposals (Banks 1980), the Consensus Development Conferences (Asch and Lowe 1984), and in the 1983 U.S. National Academy of Sciences proposal to distinguish between risk assessment and risk management (NAS 1983). Historically, professionalization has given rise to independent, and certified, advisory roles, for instance in radiation protection (Serwer 1978), and such professionalization has often occurred in response to a demand for expert advice that would resolve conflictual issues, e.g. water quality measurements in environmental debates. Increasing pressures on expert advice have changed the rules of the advisory game and made the notion of independent, objective, advice less plausible (Rip 1985). Institutional or procedural independence as such may be a necessary condition, but the real issue is the quality of the scientific advice. In itself, this raises difficult questions, since the production of quality within science is now recognized to be a bootstrap operation. Advances can often only be made by assuming the validity of at least part of the thesis to be tested. Lavoisier's famous experiments to disprove the phlogiston theory by weighing reactants and products rested on the assumption that any weight deficits were due to the production of oxygen. Although one might argue for interpretive flexibility and thus for some form of relativism, this is not the main issue here. Rather, the controlled production of effects, even if successful only within the protected confines of a laboratory, allows science to make robust claims. As soon as there is outside utilization of
Author: Arie Rip
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2578760085
FWCI: 1.808
Cites: 16
Cited by: 38
Related to: 10