Judgements during information seeking : policy and research workers' assessments of enough information
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis examines how people determine they have enough information, a \nfundamental but perplexing question for human information behaviour researchers. \nInformed by theories of human judgement and decision making, the thesis investigates \nthe ways in which judgements of enough information are made and the subtleties that \nshape this critical judgement. \nThe empirical work that underpinned the thesis was an exploratory study conducted \nfrom an interpretive orientation and using the case study approach. The study examined \nmultiple cases of judgements of enough information made while seeking and using \ninformation in the workplace. Semi-structured interviews (33) were conducted with \npublic sector policy and research workers in Australia. Two interviews were carried out, \nthe first with individual participants to explore the nature of the contexts in which they worked and the second, a paired interview with two participants to focus on how they \nassessed they had enough information. Interviews were taped and transcribed and \ninductive data analysis carried out. \nPrincipal findings included the importance of task in shaping judgements of enough \ninformation through an iterative and fluid process. Throughout the process the nature of \nwhat constituted enough information changed. Factors in the information use \nenvironment of the policy and research workers that shaped their judgements of enough \ninformation included the views of colleagues, supervisors and stakeholders, \norganisational decision making processes and organisational attitudes towards \nuncertainty. The collaborative information seeking and use of the policy and research \nworkers resulted in collaborative judgements of enough information. \nThe research makes three contributions to the field of human information behaviour \nresearch. Firstly findings provide new insights into judgements of enough information \nmade by the policy and research workers, illuminating the judgement of enough \ninformation as a process and refining concepts critical to understanding judgements \nmade while seeking and using information. Secondly the study provides a rich \ndescription of policy and research workers, a professional group not previously studied \nin relation to enough information, and their role in the public policy process. Thirdly \nconcern about the limitations of behavioural decision theory to fully explain judgements \nof enough information led to consideration of naturalistic decision making, a recent \ndevelopment in decision theory. Naturalistic decision making affords a different \nperspective on human judgement and decision making. As a conceptual framework \nwithin which to develop more nuanced understandings of judgements and decision \nmaking during information seeking, naturalistic decision making has much to offer \nhuman information behaviour researchers.
Author: JM Berryman
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2580320337
