The influence of red colouration on human perception of aggression and dominance in neutral settings
Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: For both humans and nonhuman species, there is evidence that red colouration signals both \nemotional states (arousal/anger) and biological traits (dominance, health, and testosterone). The \npresence and intensity of red colouration correlates with male dominance and testosterone in a \nvariety of animal species, and even artificial red stimuli can influence dominance interactions. \nDepending on the context in which it is perceived, red is associated with reward (e.g., mating) or \navoidance of threat. Wearing red can therefore be advantageous in romantic or achievement \ncontexts. It may also increase the probability of winning sporting contests. Both perceiver effects \nand wearer effects have been proposed as sources of enhanced winning chances for competitors \nwearing red in sporting competitions. We tested the hypothesis that artificial (clothing) colour can \nexploit the evolutionary associations between red and dominance/aggression and that this link is \neven detectable in neutral (non-competitive) settings. The first two experiments investigated \nwhether a person wearing red was perceived as more aggressive/dominant than one wearing blue \nor grey. We detected a perceiver effect for red-wearers for perceptions of aggression, dominance, \nand anger that was independent of a wearer effect. This confirmed that the colour red may be a cue \nused to predict propensity for dominance and aggression in human males. We then explored \ndifferences in handgrip strength, self- and peer-assessed dominance, and actual dominant \nbehaviour to test the hypothesis that red-wearers are physically and mentally stronger/more \ndominant than their blue-wearing opponents. Red-wearers were not stronger or perceived as more \ndominant or taller than blue-wearers, but we found some evidence that they may have acted more \ndominantly. However, in an online experiment rather than in a controlled laboratory setting, we \nfound no wearer or perceiver effects on ratings of perceived dominance, height, or strength. \nPossible limitations of web-based approaches are discussed. Finally, we examined the \nconsequences of allowing participants to choose from the full colour spectrum rather than forcing \nthem to pick from only two or three clothing colours presented. When allowed to choose from the \nfull spectrum, participants predominantly chose red shirts to make a person appear more \naggressive or more dominant. There is some qualitative evidence for an “optimal red” in that \nparticipants’ choices clustered within a specific part of the red spectrum and no such clustering or \ncolour preference was found for any of the control character traits. Overall, the results demonstrate \nthat, in a laboratory setting, the colour red can have consistent effects on perceptions of aggression \nand dominance; this opens up a broad array of avenues for future work. These findings also have \nimplications for non-academic contexts (e.g., whether wearing red can impact one’s performance \nin achievement contexts such as sporting contests or job interviews).
Author: Diana Wiedemann
Institution: Durham University
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2586499873
