Work

South Gloucestershire diabetes prevention pilot project: Full evaluation report

Year: 2016
Type: report
Abstract: Introduction \nType 2 diabetes is a serious, expensive and growing public health challenge. In England, national guidance recommends intensive lifestyle interventions promoting weight loss for people at risk of diabetes, and programmes of individualised care, information and advice for those recently diagnosed with type 2 diabetes (NICE, 2012; NICE, 2015). As NHS England rolls out an ambitious National Diabetes Prevention Programme (NDPP), it is essential that areas develop the staff skills, organisational capacity and local insight to make the most of this initiative. The South Gloucestershire Diabetes Prevention (pilot) Project (SGDPP) reflects priorities identified in Bristol North Somerset and South Gloucestershire (BNSSG)’s Sustainability and Transformation Plan (STP) on the urgent need for evidence on the implementation, effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of innovative service models for the prevention of diabetes. \n \nSouth Gloucestershire Diabetes Prevention Pilot Project \nThe SGDPP developed from a successful bid to Health Education South West in 2015. It was led by South Gloucestershire Council’s Public Health & Wellbeing Division, in collaboration with NHS South Gloucestershire CCG, Sirona Health, and Leap Valley Surgery. The pilot built upon the X-PERT Prevention of Diabetes (X-POD) programme, which consists of a six-week group education course followed by telephone and email support, with meetings scheduled at three months post-course, and again at six months post-enrolment. The design of the programme is compliant with NICE (2012) guidelines on the prevention of diabetes. The pilot was delivered between January and November 2016 through Leap Valley Surgery, offered to patients aged 35-75 years-old and at risk of diabetes – defined by body mass index (BMI) >30kgm2 recorded in the last five years, plus a key diabetes risk factor such as raised blood glucose (HbA1c; 42-47mmol/mol). \n \nEvaluation research questions and methods \nThe main evaluation questions were: \n1. What were the impacts of the SGDPP on the health and wellbeing of participants at six months post-enrolment? \n2. How was the SGDPP implemented, with specific reference to the development of referral pathways, training for delivery staff, and stakeholder perceptions? \n3. What were the costs per person associated with the delivery of the pilot? \n \nThe evaluation of the SGDPP pilot consisted of a before and after assessment of the biometric (weight, BMI, HbA1c level) and self-reported psychosocial outcomes of participants enrolled on the pilot. This was accompanied by a process evaluation of perceptions of the programme by participants, project staff and wider stakeholders, and a unit cost economic evaluation. SGDPP staff collected biometric and psychosocial questionnaire measures, inputted this data, and collected the financial data. UWE researchers developed the evaluation plan, conducted qualitative data collection, and undertook most aspects of data analysis. \n \nParticipation in the project and evaluation \nOut of 300 patients invited by letter, 95 (32%) enrolled, and 87 (29%) completed the course to the six-month stage. An additional four partners, who found they also met the inclusion criteria, enrolled and completed the programme to the six-month stage. \n \nDrop out from the project and evaluation was very low – of the 99 individuals who started, only eight (8%) were unable to attend the six-month meeting and provide evaluation data at this point. \n \nAttendance at each group education session and the six-month follow-up meeting did not fall below 84% capacity, with mean attendance for sessions at 90% capacity. Sixty-three (63.6%) participants attended all six group sessions. The mean contact time at group sessions was 10.7 ± 2.4 hours. \n \n \nParticipants provided very positive feedback on the group education sessions – 96% (90) gave a score of 9 or 10 when asked how much they would recommend the course to friends or family (where ‘0’ is extremely unlikely and ‘10’ is extremely likely). \n \n \nCharacteristics of participants at enrolment \nKey characteristics of the 99 participants at enrolment were: \n• 61.6% (61) female and 99% (98) White British \n• 64.6% (64) aged 65 years and above. Mean 64.5 ± 8.2 years. Range 37 to 76 years of age \n• 69.7% (68) retired \n• 34.4% (34) highest educational attainment was up to 16 years at secondary school \n• No participants were resident in an area in the top two national deciles for multiple deprivation; this reflects the demographic characteristics of the GP surgery’s catchment. Nearly half (48.5%, n=48) were resident in an area of lowest deprivation (decile 10 in the Index of Multiple Deprivation, IMD). \n• 69.7% (69) were obese, and 22.2% (22) overweight \n• 52.5% (52) had a family history of diabetes \n• 6.6% (4) of female participants had a history of gestational diabetes \n• 70.7% (70) had a comorbidity; 34.3% had high blood pressure and 30.3% had arthritis \n• 17.2% (17) reported a disability \n• 24.2% (24) were taking part/or recently took part in another healthy lifestyle activity, such as a walking group, sport group or weight management group \n \n \n \nOutcomes at six months \nThere were significant improvements for all measures, apart from those relating to mental wellbeing and mental ill health. The main outcomes relating to weight change for 91 participants at six months can be expressed as follows: \n• The mean weight loss was 4.04kg (SD 4.62) \n• 52.3% (45) achieved >3% weight loss \n• 40.7% (35) achieved >5% weight loss \n• 12.8% (11) achieved >10% weight loss \n• Excluding participants with normal weight, i.e. BMI<25kg/m2, 60.5% (52) achieved 2kg weight loss. At the outset of the evaluation, we set 2kg weight loss as our minimum clinically important difference (MCID). \n \nFurther analysis found that: \n• Males lost more weight than females (Males: M = -5.85kg ± 4.79; females: M = -2.97kg ± 4.19; t (89) = -3.00, p=0.003) \n• Participants living in areas of higher deprivation lost more weight than those resident in less deprived areas (Higher IMD decile: M = -5.58kg ± 5.45; lower IMD decile: M = -2.95 ± 3.58; t (59.3) = -2.60, p=0.012) \n \nThere were no associations, or associations could not be determined due to small sample sizes, between weight loss and age category, employment status or educational level. Stepwise multiple regression results found that gender, followed by area deprivation, were predictors of weight change at six months post-enrolment (p<0.01). Three other factors – contact time at group sessions, co-morbidities, and prior and/or concurrent engagement with other healthy lifestyle activities – were not predictors of weight change. \n \nProcess evaluation findings: Participants \nData were collected from fourteen focus groups (total of 62 participants), five one-to-one and telephone interviews, and written feedback from one participant. The qualitative data suggest that the organisation, clarity of goals, and personal qualities of the delivery team were essential aspects of the success of the programme. These features appear to have supported the strong uptake and retention to the programme, satisfaction with the group-based format, and commitment of participants to achieve goals that directly reduce their risk of diabetes. The programme content was broadly well received and has underpinned what was perceived to be valuable new knowledge for participants. \n \nParticipants had a range of suggestions about the development and rollout of the programme. Staff need to be fully prepared to respond to queries following mail-outs of the initial GP surgery letter of invitation. This was felt to be an especially important moment for engagement given that individuals may be surprised or shocked, and will want further information. The programme itself would benefit from further revisions to make some aspects of the course less complicated, particularly the aspects covering biological/medical education on diabetes and the dietary advice. However, participants recognised that this was challenging given the nature of the subject matter. Some participants also felt that there could be more emphasis on physical activity goals and tips on changing levels of physical activity. Opportunities for networking between groups and for keeping up contacts after the programme could help people maintain changes and share their learning as part of wider community initiatives. \n \nProcess evaluation findings: Staff and wider stakeholders \nInterview and written feedback was provided by three staff members directly involved in delivery, two expert patients and two GP surgery staff. As part of an expert panel, ten practitioners (external to the programme) from the local authority, GP practices, local CCGs, and community and voluntary sector agencies provided feedback on early stage results of the pilot evaluation in September 2016. \n \nThe pilot project was perceived by staff and stakeholders to have performed very strongly. Take-up (at 29%) and retention (at 92%) were considerably higher than the Project Steering Group anticipated. Based upon work in other areas, the group anticipated recruiting no more than 20% of invitees and retaining under 80% of those originally enrolled at six months. The outcome results also compared very favourably to similar programmes. Staff and stakeholders felt that a number of reasons could account for the project’s performance. \n \nPrior to the pilot, the delivery team had not run a diabetes prevention project. However, staff drew upon their extensive track record in running similar lifestyle education initiatives and combined this with special
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2588084233
Cites: 17
Cited by:
Related to: 10