Work

Qualitative and Quantitative Effects of Surprise: (Mis)estimates, Rationales, and Feedback-Induced Preference Changes While Considering Abortion

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: The Numerically Driven Inferencing (NDI) paradigm, and one of its methods, EPIC (Estimate, Prefer, Incorporate, and Change), are used to study both one's estimates and the effects of numeric feedback on one's personal policies (herein, about abortion).Both quantitatively and qualitatively, 92 undergraduates offered estimates and preferences for the legal U.S. abortion rate, explaining and justifying them.After receiving the (usually, quite surprising) true rate as feedback, they provided another (typically changed) preference-andrationale. Results show that people vastly underestimated the abortion rate, and largely advocated decreases in it--both preand post-feedback.Feedback caused most of those who initially wanted no change in the abortion rate both to abandon the status quo and change preference-justifications; after feedback, two thirds of these students preferred a rate decrease, while the rest preferred an increase.Although many researchers hold that belief revision and conceptual change are quite difficult to elicit, these and other results show dramatic effects of simple base rate feedback on policy evaluation.Our findings highlight the importance of having and using data when reasoning about society-engaging topics such as abortion rates.This experiment represents a new way to study numerically-based reasoning that includes the subjective natures of our personal beliefs and social lives.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2588877188
FWCI: 0.598
Cites: 9
Cited by: 19
Related to: 8