Work

Knowledge transfer and exchange: a look at the literature in relation to research and policy

Year: 2013
Type: book
Abstract: Within the field of health policy, there have been widespread calls for the increased or improved use\nof evidence within policy making. This reflects an ambition to deliver better policy in terms of\noutcomes, resource efficiency and effectiveness, and a belief that this can be achieved through\nutilising the available evidence to inform and guide decision making. For those tasked with\nimproving the uptake of a piece or body of evidence, for policy makers aiming to improve their\nevidence use, or for researches investigating this question, a number of conceptual questions remain\non how to actually achieve this, such as:\n What should count as evidence for policy making?\n Who should govern (or steer) the use of research evidence for policy?\n What is ‘good evidence’ for decision making?\n What is the ‘good use’ of evidence from a governance perspective?\n How is research knowledge typically translated into policy?\n How can one ‘improve’ the use or uptake of evidence in policy making?\nThe GRIP-Health Project is a 5 year, European Research Council supported programme of work that\naims to improve the use of research evidence in health policy through undertaking research on the\npolitical aspects of health policy making and evidence use. The project has developed a number of\nworking papers that engage with some of these topics.1\nThis current paper is concerned with the last\ntwo of the questions listed above, specifically reviewing key aspects of Knowledge Transfer and\nExchange (KTE) related to getting research into policy and practice.\nWhile the health sector is increasingly motivated by a desire to get research evidence into policy,\noutside the field of health there is a much broader body of work that is specifically concerned with\nhow evidence and knowledge are transferred, translated, or taken up by different policy actors.\nVarious theories attempt to establish how KTE works, the contextual factors that influence the\nprocess, and how to achieve maximum impact for relevant bodies of evidence. Acronyms and\nterminology used in this field vary accordingly, and can include knowledge transfer, knowledge\ntranslation, knowledge management, and knowledge brokering. These various terms have been\ngrouped together under the rubric ‘K*’ by some authors to reflect the multiple overlapping terms\n2\nPrior working papers in this series deal with aspects of: Stewardship of health evidence; hierarches and\nappropriateness of evidence; and institutional approaches to evidence uptake research. Working papers and\nother outputs of the programme are available at the GRIP-Health website\nhttp://www.lshtm.ac.uk/groups/griphealth/resources/index.html\n3\n(c.f. Shaxson et al., 2012). However, in this paper, we use the term KTE to refer to the general body\nof literature focused on issues of knowledge production, dissemination, uptake and use in\npolicymaking.\nAs the body of work on KTE is extensive, it was decided not to attempt a complete or systematic\nreview of the literature. There are, however, several papers which attempt to synthesise the existing\nliterature or systematically review elements of the KTE field. These reviews provide a starting point\nfor mapping the field to help inform efforts to improve the use of research evidence in policy. The\ncurrent paper therefore has two objectives. First, it summarises and synthesises a set of identified\nKTE review papers in order to undertake a comparison of their similarities and their differences on\nthe main areas they cover, to provide a basic mapping of key KTE concepts. After this, it then\nexplores some key themes that emerge from the KTE literature which are of particular relevance to\nthe GRIP-Health programme and other researchers or stakeholders who are tasked with improving\nevidence uptake.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2589020525
FWCI: 0.667
Cites: 38
Cited by: 5
Related to: 9