Black, white, or whatever: Examining racial identity and profession with white pre-service teachers
Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: White educators comprise between 85-92% of the current teaching force in the United States.Often contemporary research in education investigates aspects of education without examining the nature of those who do the work of educating the nation"s public school children.When educational researchers examine teachers, the research is often related to the pedagogical practices of teachers, and is void of earnest discussion of the identity of the teachers, how that identity impacts teacher beliefs about students and families, and ultimately how teachers frame their work educating students.Far less research exists that attempts to look at pre-service teachers" identity, although pre-service teachers go on to do the work of teachers after their training.This study explores the nature of pre-service teacher"s narratives as a means of understanding teachers" identity in general, and the nature of teacher White Racial Identity specifically.I conducted a series of interviews with nine white pre-service teachers to understand the nature of their identity and beliefs and I also examined my auto-ethnographic self.Findings were derived from layered data analysis that included transcription, open coding, case writing, and cross-case coding.Findings revealed that participants in the study used semantic moves and discourse structures to present beliefs about race, have underdeveloped understandings of their choice to be teachers, and used a variety of techniques in explaining their own white iii racial development; the techniques included linking diversity to race, attaching identity to racial "others," and exhibiting a lack of coherence with respect to discussing their own white racial identity.Findings and their respective sub-findings are presented with discussion.Implications of the research focus on how to help white pre-service educators better understand their whiteness and the implications of white supremacy and racism.The aim of the implications is to help teacher educators and pre-service teacher candidates work against the privileges of whiteness and to engage students in culturally relevant ways.iv Dedication To the nation"s children who suffer greatly at the hands of adults; do not replicate the nonsense to which we socialize you.v Acknowledgements I humbly acknowledge the nearly 80 million school-aged children in the United States, and especially children of color.This dissertation does little to change the hundreds of years of antiquated, under-funded, and racist education that you have received from a white supremacist educational system, but I hope that this dissertation study changes some pedagogical practices in teacher education.My hope is that you receive better, more competent, and socially just teachers who will better serve your needs.Dr. Cynthia Tyson, your scholarship taught me neither to fear critique nor to shy away from saying the hard things that need to be said.Your scholarship model helped me to think carefully about the analysis of my data, ensuring that I was fair and just in my standpoint, even when what I have to say might not be popular amongst those I critique.Thank you for your patience with me through my process and being a part of my work from before generals all the way through this dissertation.Asante Sana!Dr. Peter Demerath: I appreciate your willingness and time in working with
Author: Kenneth J. Fasching-Varner
Institution: The Ohio State University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2593803371
