Work

The Development of Criminal Suspicion by State Troopers During Traffic Stops

Year: 2007
Type: article
Abstract: How law enforcement officers exercise their discretion has importance for issues of public trust and confidence, the fair treatment of citizens, the legality of government agent behavior, and the effectiveness of their actions in achieving legitimate goals.The present study was a preliminary exploration into how state troopers develop suspicion upon which to base their searches of motor vehicles during traffic stop encounters.Utilizing a qualitative analysis of the responses of 148 state law enforcement officers who participated in sixteen focus group interviews, the present study investigated what factors state troopers rely upon during traffic stop encounters to build suspicion that criminal activity is afoot.More specifically it examined what words, behaviors, and objects sparked the suspicions of state troopers involved in highway criminal interdiction efforts.The results indicated that the respondents relied upon a number of suspiciousness cues such as the statements of the motorists, the objects they observed in relation to the vehicle, and the display of nonverbal indications of nervousness.The respondents insisted that they did not rely on a narrow list of suspiciousness indicators, but rather took a totality of the circumstances approach.Finally, variation in the suspiciousness indicators used was revealed between the respondents who were more successful and less successful than their peers in the detection of illegal contraband.
Author: Richard R. Johnson
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2596926281
FWCI:
Cites: 61
Cited by:
Related to: 10