Political Competition and Judicial Independence in Non-Democracies
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation examines the relationship between political competition and judicial independence in non-democratic polities.In it I advance two key arguments.The first is that the common "political insurance" explanation of judicial independence in democracies, predicated on the incentivizing effects of electoral competition, should also offer insights to explaining independence outside the democratic context.The second argument is that when present, electoral competition should be of greater salience in non-democracies due to the significantly higher risks associated with losing office in a non-democratic regime.I begin by discussing the concept of judicial independence and approaches in the existing literature seeking to explain variation in judicial independence in democracies, and how the literature fails to adequately address the question of regime type.I then address in Chapter 2 a fundamental aspect of the insurance model of independence that to date has been assumed but never empirically examined, showing that independent courts are highly associated with positive outcomes for leaders after leaving office.Tests of the two main arguments are presented over four chapters.Chapters 3 and 4 examine non-democracies exclusively, testing the first argument and finding that it holds up across different measures of the key concepts.Chapters 5 and 6 address the conditional relationship between competition and regime type, showing both globally and in an extended I would first and foremost like to express my gratitude for the hard work and support shown by my dissertation committee.Steve Hanson was there from the very beginning.His breadth of knowledge and conceptual clarity, both with regard to the postcommunist world and comparative politics broadly, serve as examples one can only strive to emulate.Although Victor Menaldo joined my committee only at the end, his role was critical: in the key home stretch his door was always open and the advice was always plentiful.Steve Pfaff went above and beyond in his role as the Graduate School Representative on the committee; it is only because I had the fortunate luck of his home being the Department of Sociology that he filled this role and escaped serving as an official member.His intellectual curiosity, convivial nature, and generosity have aided in my development as a scholar enormously.Much if not most of my success in graduate school can be attributed directly to my chair, Margaret Levi.I cannot begin to calculate, let alone repay, the debt to which I owe her for her unflagging support, from the first seminar the first week of my studies years ago to today.All I can say is thank you.The collegial environment of the Department of Political Science at the UW was invigorating, and I owe many thanks to countless faculty members and fellow graduate students.The Center for Statistics and the Social Sciences is an amazing resource, but I truly have Chris Adolph and Mike Ward to thank for what methods skills I possess.Aseem Prakash provided invaluable advice over the years, and I don't regret following any that I did.Peter May went far above and beyond the call of duty for someone so far removed from my work; I'd almost consider
Author: Brad Epperly
Institution: University of Washington
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2599981640
