Work

The Science of Technology and Human Behavior: Standards, Old and New

Year: 2017
Type: editorial
Abstract: The PresentTechnology and Human Behavior -a title that could not be more generic for a Special Issue.On its face, the phenomena examined in this issue are not distinct from others published in the Journal of Media Psychology (JMP): Can immersive technology be used to promote pro-environmental behaviors?(Soliman, Peetz, & Davydenko); How do subtitles and complexity of MOOC-type videos impact learning outcomes?(van der Zee, Admiraal, Paas, Saab, & Giesbers); Does cooperative video game play foster prosocial behavior?(Breuer, Velez, Bowman, Wulf, & Bente); What is the role of video game use in the unique risk environment of college students?(Holz Ivory, Ivory, & Lanier); Do interactive narratives have the potential to advocate social change?(Steinemann, Iten, Opwis, Forde, Frasseck, & Mekler).What makes this issue special is not a thematic focus, but the nature of the scientific approach to hypothesis testing: It is explicitly confirmatory.All five studies are registered reports which are reviewed in two phases: First, the theoretical background, hypotheses, methods, and analysis plans of a study are peer-reviewed before the data are collected.If they are evaluated as sound, the study receives an "in-principle" acceptance, and researchers proceed to conduct it (taking potential changes or additions suggested by the reviewers into consideration).Consequently, the data collected can be used as a true (dis-)confirmatory hypothesis test.In a second step, the soundness of the analyses and discussion section are reviewed, but the publication decision is not contingent on the outcome of the study (see our call for papers; Elson, Przybylski, and Krämer, 2015).All additional, nonpreregistered analyses conducted are clearly labelled as exploratory and serve to discover alternative explanations or generate new hypotheses.Further, the authors were required to provide a sampling plan designed to achieve at least 80% statistical power (or comparable criterion for Bayesian analysis strategies) for all of their confirmatory hypothesis tests, and to make all materials, data, and analysis scripts freely available on the Open Science Framework (OSF) at https://osf.io/5cvkr/.We believe that making these materials available to anyone increases the value of the research
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2600469354
Cites: 28
Cited by: 29
Related to: 10