The formation of social democratic parties. Degrees of inclusion as external constraints and the strategic choices of labor elites
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: The role of political and socio-economic 'alienation'…………………………………………652 2 Context and logic for the emergence of different models of labor politics……………………653 3 Varying degrees of labor inclusion and the possibility of social democratic party formation…………………………………………………………..654 4 Labor politics during the formative stage of labor's entry into the political arena and the transformation of social democracy………………………………..655 5 Decision analysis for labor elites' choices in different environments of labor inclusion……...656 6 Historical development of the economically active world population in different sectors of the economy…………………………………………………………….657xii CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION"Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please; they do not make it under circumstances chosen by themselves, but under circumstances directly encountered, given, and transmitted from the past.The tradition of all the dead generations weighs like a nightmare on the brain of the living."Karl Marx, 18th Brumaire (1852) "(Social democracy) is a revolutionary but not a revolution-making party.(…) Our task is not to organize the revolution, but to organize ourselves for the revolution."Karl Kautsky, The road to power (1909) "(To establish) a distinct Labour group in Parliament, who shall have their own whips, and agree upon their policy, which must embrace a readiness to co-operate with any party which for the time being may be engaged in promoting legislation in the direct interests of labour" James Keir Hardie, Motion to the first conference of the Labour Representation Committee (1900)"The organizations of revolutionaries must consist first and foremost of people whose profession is that of a revolutionary.(…) Give us an organization of revolutionaries, and we shall overturn the whole of Russia!"Lenin, What is to be done?(1902) "(F)reedom can be created only by freedom, that is, by a universal rebellion on the part of the people and free organization of the toiling masses from the bottom up." Mikhail Bakunin, Statism and Anarchy (1873)"The Federation has maintained that economic organization is adequate to deal with all of the problems of wage-earners.Its political action is simply to utilize the functions of trade unions in another field."Samuel Gompers, Seventy Years of Life and Labor (1924) 1 Kautsky, Hardie, Lenin, Bakunin and Gompers offer an eclectic variety of solutions for the same task:how to advance the interests of the emerging working-class in the political arena.The models suggested by Kautsky and Hardie have become the most popular ones in the labor movements of the late 19 th and early 20 th century.Both of them entail the formation of mass-based social democratic parties, and the call for socialism as a fundamental objective.But the strategies suggested to achieve that goal feature important differences.Hardie stands for evolutionary progress toward socialism, within the existing institutional environment, while Kautsky envisions a type of social democratic party that combines a rhetorical emphasis on revolutionary change with pragmatic efforts of mobilization and organization building.conscious actors make decisions, but the circumstances alone do not determine their choices.The explanation I am suggesting also extends to those instances, where choices for some model of labor politics don't match theoretical predictions derived from underpinning 'structural' determinants.I argue that varying ways for labor to enter the political arena occur as choices of labor elites in response to varying degrees of labor inclusion.Labor inclusion as the 'encountered environment' is defined by the extent of labor's institutional and behavioral integration into some given polity.It represents the external constraints on labor elites' decision making process about how to advance the interests of their constituency in the arena of politics.When labor elites make optimal choices, the model of labor politics they adopt can be predicted through an assessment of labor inclusion as the 'encountered environment'.When labor elites make suboptimal choices due to the effects of exogenous factors on their decisionmaking process, outcomes move 'off the equilibrium path'.I understand optimality as a choice for a model of labor politic that provides the most rewarding ratio of costs and benefits in some given environment.When labor inclusion is at the comparatively highest level, moderate syndicalism, as it is suggested by Gompers, is the optimal response.Insurrectionism, either through Lenin's bolshevism, or through anarchism-syndicalism, associated with Bakunin, is the optimal model of labor politics in an environment of comparatively lowest inclusion.Social democratic parties represent the optimal choice of labor elites to the two categories of inclusion located in the middle: when labor inclusion is low, quasi-revolutionary social democracy is the optimal model; when it is higher, evolutionary social democracy is optimal.The empirical analysis conducted in this dissertation will reveal that in the vast majority of cases, actors made decisions that are to be expected on the basis of circumstances "transmitted from the past": in 17 out of 20 investigated cases -a comprehensive set of sufficiently industrialized countries -labor elites adopted a model of labor politics that represents an optimal response to a particular degree of labor inclusion.An analysis into exogenous effects on labor elites' decision-making process will provide a systematic explanation for the factors that moved the three remaining outcomes 'off the equilibrium path'.It will also provide the opportunity to understand, how in some of the cases characterized by generally optimal choices, labor elites made specific decisions that decreased the degree of success, or institutionalization, accomplished through the model of labor politics they adopted. Alternative explanationsOther than the argument sketched here, the existing explanations for social democratic party formation are exclusively structural and deterministic: they relate a particular aspect of the environment encountered by the labor movement at large to the variety of observable outcomes.A 'socio-economic' approach was first explicitly suggested by Bull (1922) and later extended by Galenson (1952).From this
Author: Konstantin Vössing
Institution: The Ohio State University
Language: English
Topic: Labor Movements and Unions
Subfield: Industrial relations
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2601198719
