Work

The Impact of Presumptive Sentencing Guidelines on Disparity in Sentencing in Ohio

Year: 2002
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: In the past three decades, various forms of structured felony sentencing schemes have been developed in numerous states and the federal government as a response to the perceived inadequacies of earlier, indeterminate, parole-based sentencing systems.Among the types of structured sentencing systems developed are commission-based guidelines, in which a legislatively established "sentencing commission" develops a sentencing package for approval by lawmakers.The stated goals of such reforms usually include certainty of punishment for lawbreakers and the reduction of unwarranted disparity in sentencing by race or any other "extra-legal" factors.While many observers believe that these various reforms have generally been successful in reducing unwarranted disparity in sentencing, the evidence used to support such a claim is often methodologically weak.In this study, the direct effect on unwarranted racial disparity of Ohio's Senate Bill 2, a presumptive guidelines system established in 1996, is examined in an effort to help improve the quality of research examining this question.Multi-phase logistic regression analyses of samples of felony cases drawn before and after Senate Bill 2 in Hamilton County and Franklin County Ohio were conducted, and few differences in the charge reduction or guilty plea phases were found.However, in the imprisonment decision, it was found that young, African-American males were significantly more likely to be imprisoned, net of other factors, but there was no such significant finding in the post-Senate Bill 2 model.The results could suggest a positive impact of the Bill in reducing unwarranted disparity, but the findings are weakened in that there was no significant change of the importance of the interaction of age, race, and sex between the pre-and post-SB 2 model.The implications of this and other findings are discussed. AcknowledgmentsFirst and foremost, I wish to thank my mentor and advisor, John Wooldredge, who made the project upon which this dissertation is based possible.Without his contribution to the data collection, methodological expertise, co-authorship of the grant proposal, and sterling reputation with the appropriate federal authorities, the world might forever be in the dark about the effects of Senate Bill 2. I also want to thank Fritz Rauschenberg, and his collaborator in public service, David Diroll of the Ohio Criminal Sentencing Commission, for their participation in the project as completely willing partners.Fellow graduate students Travis Pratt, Colleen Kadleck, and Jeff Maas (and Fritz and the Fritzlings, on occasion) did a superb job in helping with the data collection and in promoting the economic health of Clifton liquor establishments.I wish all of them continued academic/professional success in their various new positions.Special recognition must be given
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2602638792
FWCI:
Cites: 96
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9