Work

Reference comparison and decision making - effects of reference point salience on decision making under risk

Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Decision making theories were originally built around the assumption that individual’s decisions are mainly\ndependent on the monetary outcomes of the decider. This paper explores whether social comparison and\ncontrolling the salience of social comparison can change evaluation of choices and preference for risk. The\nhypothesis is that they can. Early expected utility models modeled risk aversion by assigning different\nshapes to an individual’s utility function. The relatively simple structure of the expected utility model\nprovided a readily understandable tool for predicting decision making under risk. It also contained some\nproblems related to the underlying assumptions which the model was based on. Later developments in\neconomic decision making theory aimed to solve the observed problems and include more factors in to the\nmodels. Prospect theory and social preferences models are among these developments in decision making\ntheory. Decision making, as described by these models, can also depend on results attained by other\npeople. Psychological research on decision making has a longer line of research and can contribute more to\nreference person selection, effects of emotions and social pressure. This paper will present two economic\ndecision making theories, relevant for the subject of social comparison and risk taking, and provide\nadditional review of relevant psychological research. In addition to the literature review, a hypothetical\nexperiment, plausible results and possible implications are discussed in the end.\n\nFINDINGS\n\nProspect theory and social preferences model include a reference person in the evaluation of an outcome\nand provide a modeling possibility for estimating how these reference persons could affect decision making.\nBoth models predict that increasing the salience of a reference person’s outcomes and comparison will\nchange risk taking in individuals. In prospect theory, salience is predicted to moderate the perceived\ndistance to a reference point. Increasing salience of social comparison is expected to increase the perceived\ndifference to reference point. In social preferences model, the outcome of a reference person is included in\nthe utility function and the parameters are expected to react to changing salience conditions. Changing\nparameters would change marginal utility of the utility function altering predicted risk preferences.\n\nPsychological research helps further understand how reference persons are selected, what effects\nemotions and social pressure can have. Reference people are selected mainly due to the fact that people\nhave a need to evaluate their actions and in some fields finding a suitable measure is difficult. In subjective\nsituations, other people provide a convenient way to measure ones abilities and success. Findings in\nresearch on social pressure support the hypothesis and include support on the moderating effect of\nsalience on risk taking. Finally, previous research on emotions does not provide any conclusive evidence for\nor against the hypothesis. The prominent theories on emotions are presented and possible effects of each\nare accounted for when discussing possible results and implications.
Institution: Aalto University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2603191495
Cites: 84
Cited by:
Related to: 10