Work

The Effects of Rater and Leader Gender on Ratings of Leader Effectiveness and Attributes in a Business Environment

Year: 2005
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Male leaders are viewed as more effective than female leaders as reported in the vast majority of research studies (Eagly & Johnson, 1990;Thompson, 2000;Vecchio, 2002).Research also supports the concept that supervisors of male and female leaders, if all else is equal, rate them equally effective (Eagly & Johnson, 1990;Powell, Butterfield, & Parent, 2002).With over 800 million (Schneider, 2001) spent on leadership development, training, and education in colleges, universities, and corporations the need and importance of quality and gender neutral curricula is increasingly important.The dollars spent on education and the disparity of perceptions of leader effectiveness precipitates the need to continue to examine the bases of these perceptions.The results of these examinations assist in the development of targeted leadership training and development.This study looked at both leader effectiveness and leader attributes of male and female leaders as perceived by male and female observers (peers and direct reports) and male and female supervisors.Using the Leader Effectiveness Index (LEI) and the Leader Attributes Inventory (LAI), this study examined the effectiveness and attributes of leaders in business and industry.Each leader in this study had a matching pair of male and female observers who provided their perceptions of leader effectiveness and attributes to determine the presence of gender bias.iv The study found that female leaders were viewed as more effective leaders than male leaders by both male and female observers while male and female supervisors found male and female leaders equally effective.Female leaders were perceived at having higher ratings on 17 out of 37 attributes and female observers and female supervisors rated both male and female leaders higher on selected attributes.Finally this study found that except for nine attributers where female leaders were rated higher, male and female supervisors rated male and female leaders equally on the remaining 28 attributes.The results of this study indicate that there may be a shifting of perceptions of effectiveness of male and female leaders.Leadership development programs and educational initiatives need to align the content of the curricula to foster gender-neutral perceptions of leadership effectiveness.v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This document is the culmination of an interesting and wonderful journey.There are many people to thank for their help along the way.My office staff and friends Lorrie Beatty, Mary Jean Milanko, and Pat Ray are three incredible individuals who put up with a lot during the three years of this process -their support and tolerance will always be remembered.My guide was Margie Martyn, who by going through the same process several months ahead of my own process provided me with a compassionate guidebook of what to expect.
Institution: University of Akron
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2603664313
FWCI:
Cites: 146
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10