Evolution of the Stomatal Regulation of Plant Water Content
Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: Terrestrial productivity today is regulated by stomatal movements, but this has only been the case since “stomatophytes” became dominant on the land 390 million years ago. In this review, we examine evidence for the function of early stomata, found on or near the reproductive structures of bryophyte-like fossils, and consider how this function may have changed through time as vascular plants evolved and diversified. We explore the controversial insights that have come from observing natural variation, rather than genetic manipulation, as a primary tool for understanding the function of the stomatal valve system. The variation in stomatal behavior among extant plant groups has stimulated great interest recently across diverse fields of science. Behavioral differences in the responses of stomata to water stress within plant communities have been recognized as an important axis of variation in ecological strategy (Martínez-Vilalta and Garcia-Forner, 2016; Meinzer et al., 2016), while systematic variation in stomatal size, density, and response characteristics (Santelia and Lawson, 2016) among plant clades have important implications for interpreting plant-atmosphere interactions (Franks et al., 2012; Franks e Buckley, 2017). Understanding how stomatal behavior feeds into processes of plant selection is a fundamental goal in plant science, and much progress over the past three decades has been made toward this goal by applying the tools of genetic manipulation to the model angiosperm, Arabidopsis thaliana (Schroeder et al., 2001; Hetherington and Woodward, 2003; Kim et al., 2010; Hedrich, 2012; Eisenach and De Angeli, 2017; Jezek and Blatt, 2017). A very different but potentially complementary approach, especially as we approach a postgenomics era, is the use of natural variation as a lens through which the function of stomata can be viewed from a perspective of plant selection over evolutionary time. This novel evolutionary approach to understanding stomatal function presents huge potential for enhancing our understanding of not only the influence of stomatal behavior on the colonization of land by plants, but also the key processes that govern stomatal responses in modern species. Stomatal evolution has become a focus of some debate in recent years (Brodribb et al., 2009; Brodribb and McAdam, 2011; Chater et al., 2011; Ruszala et al., 2011; Franks and Britton-Harper, 2016), largely initiated by evidence that although the stomata of ancient lineages of vascular plants open similarly to angiosperms in response to light and CO2, they close differently. In particular, the observation that stomatal conductance and transpiration of ferns and lycophytes does not significantly decline in response to abscisic acid (ABA; Brodribb and McAdam, 2011) led to the theory that stomatal closure during water stress originated in early vascular plants as a passive response of guard cells to dehydration, and that the “active” closure mechanism, mediated by ABA, evolved much later in the earliest seed plants. Debate about this theory has seen apparently contradictory evidence presented from researchers using diverse approaches. Genetic techniques are seen as the ideal means of resolving such debates, but so far this evidence has also provided confusing results about the presence and localization of necessary components required for ABA signaling in stomata (see below). In the face of equivocal physiological evidence, it is critical to consider stomatal evolution from first principles, in terms of how differences in stomatal regulation impacts plant performance. Here we focus on the evolution of stomatal regulation of plant water content, from the perspective of selection and adaptation, considering the functional role of stomata, and how this relates to variation in form, positioning, and macroscopic function observable across the phylogeny of land plants. This macroscopic perspective is essential when considering core plant processes, such as stomatal action, because adaptive changes in function are expected to have profound and measurable effects on plant performance (McElwain and Steinthorsdottir, 2017). The evolution of ABA responsiveness in land plants represents a fascinating example of how different perspectives can lead to profoundly different conclusions. For example, we know that ferns and lycophytes are capable of very fast (<5 min) stomatal closure to <10% maximum aperture during dehydration, a necessary response to prevent damage to the plant (see below). The size, speed, and shape of this closure response in ferns and lycophytes appears to be well explained by passive stomatal closure through guard cell dehydration, without any need for active processes of ion trafficking (Brodribb and McAdam, 2011). When combined with the fact that unlike angiosperms, fern and lycophyte stomata do not respond to endogenous levels of ABA (McAdam and Brodribb, 2012), the conclusion that ABA-mediated closure is not important in basal vascular plants seems robust. However, reports regularly emerge of small stomatal responses in fern and lycophyte guard cells artificially exposed to ABA levels hundreds of thousands to millions of times higher than endogenous levels (Ruszala et al., 2011; Cai et al., 2017; Hõrak et al. 2017). The reasonable conclusion from these data is that fern and lycophyte guard cells react to exceedingly high levels of ABA, but the challenge remains to understand the adaptive relevance of such observations. In this review we document recent discoveries made using an evolutionary approach to reconstructing stomatal function and consider how this adds to the classical genetic manipulation approach in a model angiosperm that has dominated stomatal biology for the past three decades. The opening and closing of stomata is a conspicuous feature of vascular land plant physiology (Darwin, 1898), and the presence of stomata on moss and hornwort sporophytes (Ziegler, 1987) as well as the epidermes of species from the oldest vascular land plant fossil assemblage, the 410 million-year-old Rhynie Chert (Edwards and Axe, 1992) suggest that these features are a critical tool for terrestrial plant survival. Despite numerous losses of stomata in the bryophytes, including in the liverworts and a number of basal moss clades (Paton and Pearce, 1957; Haig, 2013), the structure and developmental genes that guide epidermal cell fate and ultimately the differentiation of guard cells appear to be ancient and highly conserved (Vatén and Bergmann, 2012; Renzaglia et al., 2017). This archaic developmental origin of stomata raises the intriguing question of what selective pressure drove the evolution of these first adjustable pores in the earliest land plants. If the function of the earliest stomata was the same as in vascular plants, facilitating the dynamic optimization of water use against carbon gain (Cowan, 1977), then common elements of the stomatal control process likely evolved with these first stomata. This angiosperm-centric hypothesis has been long held as the best explanation for stomatal evolution (Haberlandt, 1886; Paton and Pearce, 1957; Ziegler, 1987; Chater et al., 2011), but has been recently challenged by key differences in the general behavior and apparent role of early stomata as well as recent molecular and physiological evidence indicating a highly divergent functional role for stomata in these most basal stomata-bearing land plants (Haig, 2013; Pressel et al., 2014; Field et al., 2015; Chater et al., 2016; Renzaglia et al., 2017). While the regulation of gas exchange by stomata to facilitate photosynthesis is a canon of plant physiology, based on the well-described behavior of millions of stomata concentrated on the primary photosynthetic organs of derived vascular plants (Ziegler, 1987), the placement and number of stomata in nonvascular plants and the earliest, leafless vascular plants is vastly different (Fig. 1). In the most basal land plant species, there are no stomata on the primary photosynthetic organ, the gametophyte, with guard cells located solely on the reproductive sporophyte and, in mosses, on the apophysis at the base of the capsule (Haberlandt, 1886). This is similar to a number of the earliest vascular land plant fossils, particularly the cooksonioids, which are likely the common ancestor of extant vascular plants (Gonez and Gerrienne, 2010), and from which the evidence of the oldest stomata is recorded (Edwards and Axe, 1992). These species had stomata (rarely more than three) similarly clustered around the base of the reproductive sporangia (Edwards et al., 1998). There is compelling evidence that the main sporophyte axes of these plants were not capable of autonomous photosynthesis given their anatomy and instead relied on primary photosynthesis occurring in a basal gametophyte (Boyce, 2008), much like extant bryophytes, which have very low photosynthetic activity in the sporophyte (Paolillo and Bazzaz, 1968; Thomas et al., 1978). Vast differences exist across land plant lineages in terms of stomatal density and size. Images of stomata-bearing epidermis from two unexceptional and highly representative species of respective lineages are presented to illustrate this phylogenetic difference. Left, The epidermis of the sporophyte of a stomata-bearing hornwort species the sporophyte is the only of this nonvascular plant to stomata. nonvascular plant species are by a similar and number of stomata (Paton and Pearce, 1957; Field et al., The epidermis of the angiosperm, species is the primary stomata-bearing of this and most angiosperm species. Stomatal density in this is stomata which is for the of an angiosperm (Franks and 2009; Brodribb et al., Images were at the same based on the and of the earliest fossil stomata, that stomata not a role in photosynthetic gas are by of of hornwort and moss stomata. In these plants, the stomatal and only then et al., 2014; Field et al., 2015; Renzaglia et al., 2017). This opening to a of the in the facilitating the of the sporophyte to it has been that transpiration by stomatal opening may also a of and from the basal gametophyte into the sporophyte (Haig, these have molecular by a in the moss species in which a in the of was in guard cell developmental et al., this of capsule was the only functional and plants. While a divergent role for stomata seems likely basal land plants and more derived vascular plants, the observation that stomata are apparently capable of opening that a conserved opening may across land plants. The seems to be the basal moss stomatal opening is likely a derived mechanism, by the of guard cell et al., This conspicuous of the aperture and guard cell pressure in the stomata of is not apparent in more derived or like vascular plants, stomatal opening in basal species than an in guard cell In vascular plants, particularly angiosperms, active processes essential for guard cell and opening the are well particularly in the light (Schroeder et al., 2001; et al., and 2017). This opening process is by the of the guard cell potential through the of the the guard cells and a of et al., 2001; Lawson, 2009; et al., in angiosperms this guard cell response is not to open stomata and et al., 2011; et al., in the also a for opening et al., and 2010; et al., potentially an et al., 2013), combined with et al., vascular plants, stomata and the presence of in guard cells appears to be an with of the guard cells in to epidermal cells in (Edwards et al., that these earliest stomata similarly While in angiosperms photosynthesis in the appears to a for stomatal opening in the light et al., et al., in basal vascular plants, stomatal opening in the light can be by guard photosynthesis with stomatal opening occurring in the epidermis of ferns (McAdam and Brodribb, 2012), which stomatal responses to light and open only by photosynthetic processes et al., 2015; and These data that a for stomatal opening in the light likely evolved the of seed plants (McAdam and Brodribb, The of plant stomata to respond to light in the of the may be to the high number of in the guard cells of these species guard cell photosynthesis and stomatal opening in the earliest land plants the ideal for stomatal opening to the 390 million years the of extant clades of basal vascular land plants including the and by the a in land plants, the evolution of an dominant sporophyte with photosynthetic organs in stomata. This evolutionary stomata with photosynthesis required a in the land plants stomata, from facilitating the of the sporophyte to enhancing photosynthetic gas exchange in the and the regulation of plant water gas exchange for photosynthesis in the light likely required no evolutionary in guard cell as this process be by stomata to in on to in the same basal vascular land plants open stomata. The apparent of the in the stomatal opening of appears to a common with vascular plants et al., 2011), although more in is required to this potentially ancient lycophyte and fern stomata have the to open in the light and and and Brodribb, 2012), with lycophyte stomata stomatal opening in as well as while ferns more than of fern et al., have light stomatal signaling et al., The this of light stomatal signaling in derived ferns as but may be to a an with photosynthesis in low light et al., a role for stomatal opening seems apparent across land plants, the role and process of stomatal closure seems much particularly basal plants are In vascular plants, a primary stomatal function is the to close the during water stress to transpiration and plant damage to the plant vascular (Fig. The primary selective the evolution of stomatal closure in the light are as a for water use stomatal closure at low or as a means of from is to understand how selection for water use can at the of the because water more water for (Cowan, The role a much more selective to plants and seems likely to the evolution of stomatal responses in the light et al., However, as of evidence suggest that this may not be an in stomatal including the for and in and the fact that stomata rather than in basal land plants et al., the need to control from but was likely to be with the evolution of plants that to during the of land plants and The for this is that the water in plants during water to be from water in the and This of damage can be in small plants can in the vascular et al., but plants are to by or pressure et al., 2016), and during water stress (Brodribb and 2009; and Stomatal closure to the from have been an evolutionary for the in plant that during the of vascular plants. it has been that the stomata of basal vascular plants such as ferns close the decline in function with (Brodribb and techniques that the process of that a similar role of stomatal closure in the from during water stress (Fig. is also common to and angiosperms (Brodribb et al., 2016; et al., 2017). There are of opening and closing to stomata during the early of plant for example the opening of stomata at high pressure by to low However, the closure during appears to as plants approach and 2011; et al., 2016), and et al., 2017). in the earliest vascular plants first to prevent of the vascular a function that appears to conserved the the of stomatal closure with to water potential as three plants were to and to the water potential of stomatal the process of for from three are and the of in the of three plants as they from et al. The and most means of closing a such as the stomatal when water is to a guard cells and such that the of the guard cells is to the of the a means that guard cells as water potential closing the and (Brodribb and McAdam, 2011). This means of stomatal closure in response to water no or signaling and is well in lycophytes and ferns et al., Brodribb and McAdam, 2011; et al., Stomatal responses to changes in pressure the of the are highly in these early vascular plants based on a passive model that with guard cell (Brodribb and McAdam, 2011; et al., However, there is an important for this passive to function in these basal a influence of epidermal cell on stomatal that only guard cell the aperture of the (Franks and This is very much in In angiosperms, the passive response of stomata to changes in is stomata to in the opening when and closing as This because of a guard cells and epidermal cells that results in these passive responses to water (Darwin, of this in ferns and lycophytes appears with passive control in these early of the that this of epidermal is in The stomata in these ancient plants apparently toward the of the guard cell (Edwards and Axe, much the same as extant lycophytes and ferns (Franks and et al., for which there is no of the guard cell into the epidermal a with modern angiosperms (Fig. A the in the main of guard and epidermal cell during stomatal opening in to The the of cell A passive water and guard cell in extant basal vascular plants appears to be to prevent during changes in et al., However, without more to guard cell and stomatal it has been that passive closure does not a stomatal capable of ferns and lycophytes from critical water when water is during (McAdam and Brodribb, a ferns and lycophytes in on a high plant or low stomatal density (McAdam and Brodribb, 2013), 2010), and in some rather et al., 2016) to active stomatal closing has the potential to transpiration to transpiration and Brodribb and the for species to plant water have low and of stomata. In seed plants, the presence of an active of stomatal responses to water is from diverse from the et al., and and in on guard cells and Blatt, et al., et al., 2003; et al., Jezek and Blatt, of which the presence of a stomatal This is the ABA, which is as and seed plant stomata and and et al., The molecular signaling an ABA response is well initiated by which in the of ABA to et al., 2009; et al., When ABA is to is to et al., In seed plants, by in the presence of ABA these guard best of these are the the of and cell and closing the stomatal et al., There is an of and that facilitate the of most the presence of ABA and et al., The dominant role for in this ABA signaling is by The of in the key for stomatal responses to ABA, are no to ABA et al., or et al., 2013; et al., While signaling for ABA and have been et al., 2010; et al., 2012; et al., these are and or with functional to et al., these ABA signaling an role in stomatal function is to be The core ABA signaling is highly conserved across land plants with including species without stomata, such as functional physiological responses to ABA et al., 2016), ABA in et al., 2011), and functional et al., This highly conserved ABA signaling is to et al., 2010), and in plants (McAdam et al., 2016), among essential evolutionary (Fig. were required for the of the ancient ABA into a of gas exchange in the earliest seed an guard of this and the to ABA over a to stomatal or more of these for stomatal responses does not in plants. In lycophytes and are to (McAdam et al., 2016), while a functional in et al., is not to the guard cells et al., 2011; et al., 2016) and likely a role in In angiosperms there is a of and that are in guard cells and et al., 2009; et al., 2011). this also in the first of land plants to functional stomatal responses to endogenous ABA, the remains to be The relates to the of ABA over a that apparent stomatal In terms of water this is in vascular land plants and Ziegler, et al., et al., 2009; and Brodribb, 2013), but only in angiosperm does ABA appear to over a that to the of stomatal response to (McAdam and Brodribb, key evolutionary are required for ABA to gas exchange in land plants. The of in from to and the from of a of Arabidopsis are from et al. If can then the genes these be in guard and this is the case in angiosperms and including is in the guard cells as by the profound of the of in these cells et al., gas ABA levels over a that is to the stomatal response to changes in for the from and Brodribb in ABA in that are and at water for a of This with data from the angiosperm species from et al. which like most angiosperms a in ABA only a in pressure from to these key to a phylogeny of land plants, which that are to liverworts et al., and divergent from that only in angiosperms do three of these essential physiological and molecular for gas exchange control by ABA have functional stomatal responses to ABA (McAdam and Brodribb, and ferns do not have guard of or genes (McAdam et al., 2016) it is likely that seed plants were the first land plants to a guard cell of these in angiosperms is ABA the same as the stomatal response to an in (McAdam and Brodribb, The first of land plants to respond to endogenous ABA, the is to ABA in at of water stress (McAdam and Brodribb, and these high levels to close stomata during (Brodribb et al., that the earliest ABA to prevent of the when in (Brodribb et al., unlike fern and lycophyte species, which appear of While in likely provided the selective pressure to ABA signaling into the guard the evolution of this appears to have become an important axis of variation in water use and responses to water in water use from differences in ABA is apparent in the that have to high levels of ABA in to close stomata and in (Brodribb and McAdam, species et al., 2010; et al., that plants to when water during this low water stomata close to guard cell water in the of ABA (Brodribb et al., 2014; et al., 2017). In these species, stress this critical to a decline in ABA levels to the plant but water This strategy is also with stomatal responses to and is to gas exchange and photosynthesis during (Brodribb and McAdam, While ABA an important explanation for variation in stomatal behavior within the it also appears to differences and angiosperms in their stomatal responses to water In ABA are to stomatal responses to changes in This is to a of in the ABA et al., 2011; et al., or a general in the of critical for ABA (McAdam and Brodribb, of which The of this ABA in is that stomata have and responses to changes in (McAdam and Brodribb, like the two most basal lineages of vascular plants. In angiosperms, ABA is et al., et al., 2014; et al., 2016) and can be by a in over the time of and and Brodribb, angiosperms respond to using ABA, as is by the in ABA levels in angiosperm in response to changes in et al., and Brodribb, while in ABA and signaling genes have stomatal responses to et al., et al., 2013; et al., The of this regulation of stomatal responses to by ABA is unlike vascular land plant the stomatal response to in angiosperms is and to be by passive processes et al., and Brodribb, to this in stomatal response to is an the of ABA and of which are regulated in different While ABA in response to a in is to very near to the vascular et al., ABA in an Arabidopsis is by two in vascular the in guard cells et al., These two genes have different of in that are exposed to high variation in ABA across the et al., for these two key ABA or ABA genes et al., 2011; et al., across angiosperm species to differences in the of species to remains to be the of data from representative species the land plant in are an means of physiological evolution et al., 2014; et al., 2014; et al., Stomatal some of be in with of stomatal behavior in of highly conserved stomatal developmental among land plants (Vatén and Bergmann, 2012; et al., 2016) appears to the of conserved stomatal function (Haberlandt, 1886; Paton and Pearce, 1957; Ziegler, 1987; Chater et al., 2011). However, a recent of molecular and plant by Chater et al. a divergent functional role for stomata in that is required to the function of guard cells from passive to ABA is the or of an and highly conserved ABA signaling into the guard cells (McAdam et al., However, this evolutionary be by in of which instead stomata-bearing plants have the genetic to and respond to ABA, the for the that stomata respond to recent in of differences in the ABA across land plant lineages (McAdam et al., differences in ABA (McAdam and Brodribb, remains to be There are a number of stomatal aperture that have not been in this review for which we have understanding like stomatal in plants 1987), or functional understanding like stomatal responses to than ABA to these and these responses in the of evolution is There remains much debate in the on the evolution of the stomatal response to (Brodribb et al., 2009; Franks and Britton-Harper, A common feature of in this is a conserved to respond to CO2, particularly low CO2, which likely a common photosynthetic signaling in stomata (Brodribb et al., 2009; Franks and Britton-Harper, However, differences across lineages in the stomata respond to in the and Brodribb and McAdam, as well as the influence of ABA on the of stomata to (McAdam et al., 2011) as and potentially important differences in the stomata respond to more natural endogenous and in this is required to these key abscisic acid pressure
Source: PLANT PHYSIOLOGY
DOI: 10.1104/pp.17.00078
Authors: Timothy J. Brodribb, Scott A.M. McAdam
Institution: University of Tasmania
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,851
Funder: Australian Research Council
OpenAlex ID: W2607128934
