Work

The dawn of the vertebrates: characters versus common ascent in the rise of current vertebrate phylogenies [Palaeontological Association 1995 annual address]

Year: 1996
Type: article
Abstract: Armoured fossil jawless fishes, or 'ostracoderms', have long been regarded as being ancestral to Recent hagfishes and lampreys.The latter were supposed to have lost the mineralized exoskeleton and undergone a 'degeneracy' linked with their burrowing or ectoparasitic modes of life.However, recent cladistic analyses suggest that most, if not all 'ostracoderms' are more closely related to jawed vertebrates than to either lampreys or hagfishes, although they are clearly jawless.These views are very similar to those expressed by the early British palaeontologists who made the first attempts at placing these extinct taxa in the classification of the vertebrates.The chaotic history of the phylogenetic position of the 'ostracoderms' seems to be due to varying approaches to the use of either character's or common ascent in phylogeny reconstruction.Although not very attractive as fossils, the Palaeozoic jawless vertebrates, or agnathans, have always raised interest among both professional palaeontologists and the public.This may be because they often are bizarrely shaped animals, but it is certainly because they are supposed to tell us something about the origin of the vertebrates in general.Therefore, textbooks on vertebrate evolution may sometimes overlook some major fossil taxa, but Palaeozoic jawless vertebrates are always included.During the last 150 years the principal advances in this field of vertebrate palaeontology were triggered essentially by new material and methods which gave access to more characters, in particular those based on internal anatomy and histological structure.The discovery of such new major clades as the galeaspids, arandaspids and pituriaspids has also enriched our perception of the diversity of vertebrate taxa and revealed new character combinations.As well as this progress, the expected result of more thorough investigation of material, the rise of cladistic methodology has given a new analytical dimension to the debates on the interrelationships of these early vertebrates.There is still a wide diversity of opinions on 'basal' vertebrate phylogeny, but most current theories suggest that jawed vertebrates are more closely related to one particular agnathan taxon than to others, i.e. that jawless vertebrates are not a clade.The purpose of this address is firstly, to highlight the role played by early British vertebrate palaeontologists in the rise of interest in these 'basal' vertebrates, and then to show how circumstances led to the development of a number of long-lived scenarios about their evolution, all these scenarios dependent on the way in which taxa are defined.Finally, I shall deal with propects; suggestions of investigations in this particular field, i.e. how to get more taxa and more characters.
Language: English
Subfield: Paleontology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2613605785
FWCI: 7.764
Cites:
Cited by: 138
Related to: 10