Work

The Predictive Ability of Psychological Constructs Upon Verdict Outcome: A Latent Profile Analysis of Juror Decision Making.

Year: 2017
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Ministry Of Justice (2015)34,741 Cases Recorded by Police 3,851 Cases Proceeded to Court Stage < 11% of total reported 1,297 Cases -Defendant Convicted < 4% of cases reported **UK Home Office estimates: 60,000 -95,000 Rapes per year Rape Attrition Decision to ReportVictim may never reporte.g.relationship to offender, fear disbelief, 're-raped' Investigation StageSuspect never detected, police drop due to lack of evidence or victim withdraws Discontinuation by ProsecutorsCPS decide not enough evidence to secure conviction, e.g.consent contested or victim not considered credible 4. Trial Judge dismissal or more likely Jury decide Not Guilty Jury Trials -E&W 12 Lay Jurors make verdict decisions in isolation Judges role: provide legal directions only Eligibility Criteria Inc. criteria: 18-75 & registered voter Exc.criteria: serious mental health issues / criminal convictions Randomly Selected Local electoral register No Pre-trial Questioning or Peremptory Challenges -Criminal Justice Act, 1988 Jurors prohibited from discussing case post-trial -Contempt of Court Act, 1981 No Justification for verdict required So Jury Decision Making must work just fine then… Age range 18 -73 (M = 45.00,SD = 15.75)51% females & 49% males Electoral Role -Random Comp Generation Jury Eligibility Assessed Methods Measures -Completed upon arrival Demographics questionnaire Psychopathic Personality Traits Scale (PPTS) -Boduszek et al (2016) Acceptance of Modern Myths About Sexual Aggression Scale (AMMSA) -Greger et al (2007) Self Esteem Scale -Rosenberg (1989) Completed Post-trial Verdict Decision Sheet 1 & 2
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2617461828
FWCI:
Cites: 7
Cited by:
Related to: 10