A collective case study analysis of comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs on college and university campuses
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Every year in the U.S, college students face a range of consequences as a result of alcohol consumption. College students who consume alcohol create problems not only for themselves, but also for their peers and the higher education institutions they attend. Despite all of the attention from the research community, laws created by federal and state governments, and prevention efforts put forth by higher education institutions, the degree of alcohol consumption, binge drinking, and significance of alcohol-related problems on U.S. college and university campuses has remained a serious and unchanged problem for 30 years. \nComprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs offer the greatest opportunity for positive behavior modification in college students in terms of alcohol use. The purpose of this qualitative, collective case study was to identify and explore strategies within comprehensive alcohol prevention programs at the colleges and universities which incorporate them. Of specific interest was the criteria these institutions use when selecting alcohol prevention programs and the perceived barriers that are preventing institutions which are not offering comprehensive alcohol prevention programs, from incorporating them. Data collection began with email requests for participants to complete a 10 question structured survey. From those responses, eight participants were purposively selected to participate in semi-structured interviews. In addition, documents from the institutions were requested and analyzed and institution websites were reviewed to advance further understanding of the information and increase trustworthiness of the study. Data analysis was conducted using the constant-comparative method and consisted of open and axial coding. This study is significant in that it identified best practices used by colleges and universities to develop impactful comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs and revealed the criteria these institutions use when selecting or developing these prevention programs. Trustworthiness was established through credibility, confirmability, dependability and transferability, using member checking, reflexive journaling, audit trails, and by providing thick, rich description. \n The results of this study support the effectiveness of comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs on college and university campuses. Participants described very similar program components including required alcohol education for freshmen, required interventions for students in violation of the student code of conduct regarding alcohol use, peer educator programs, and community and campus alcohol committees and coalitions. Other results from this study included: 1) the lack of a common definition of what constitutes the success of a comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention program; 2) the unanimous focus on harm reduction as opposed to an abstinence only approach to alcohol prevention; 3) various identified methods of selecting individual components that fall within the comprehensive program; and 4) perceived barriers preventing higher education institutions from implementing comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs such as the taboo nature of alcohol prevention on college campuses, an unfair perception that alcohol is a campus problem as opposed to a societal issue, and inadequate staff needed to implement comprehensive programs. \n The results of this study suggest implications and recommendations for higher education practice. Implications include: 1) the need for higher education institutions to implement comprehensive evidence-based alcohol prevention programs in order to effectively address alcohol use by students; 2) the importance of abandoning abstinence based prevention efforts to focus on the underlying issue which is reducing harm that occurs as a result of alcohol consumption; 3) the need to establish baseline data specific to the campus and develop campus specific definitions of success to determine best practices for the campus and also to avoid damaging comparisons to other colleges and universities who operate under different demographics; and 4) the necessity of administrator support in alcohol prevention initiatives to advance campus efforts. Recommendations for the practice of higher education include: 1) the need for colleges and universities to hire qualified staff to lead alcohol prevention efforts; 2) recruitment of administrative support for alcohol prevention programs; 3) community involvement in campus alcohol prevention efforts; and 4) the incorporation of evidence-based program components within the comprehensive alcohol prevention program.
Author: Amanda L. Smith
Institution: Texas Tech University
Language: English
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2620058132
