Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Introduction: The training of surgical residents has seen a tremendous shift in education and assessment paradigms over the last decade. The traditional time-based framework, which has essentially remained unchanged since its conception over a hundred years ago is being replaced, albeit slowly, by a new competency-based framework. Despite the need for such change and this almost inevitable transition, there is currently a lack of evidence to support and operationalize many education and assessment facets within this new framework. The main goal of this thesis is to collect evidence that helps bridge many of the knowledge gaps currently present in order to support the transition towards competency-based training in General Surgery. Methods: All data were prospectively collected and analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics (both parametric and non-parametric). Research designs contained within the thesis include: a systematic review in accordance with current guidelines, a census survey, a consensus Delphi methodology and two cross-sectional observation studies. Traditional and contemporary frameworks of validity (and reliability) were adhered to throughout. Results: Five research studies were completed. A systematic review, which documented the methods by which technical competence is currently assessed in surgical trainees, that there is a lack of performance standards in surgical education and how best to differentiate between the terms competency and proficiency. An international education directorateâ s census survey, which acknowledged current and ideal assessment practices across various surgical jurisdictions and barriers to the implementation of competency-based assessments at all three phases of surgical training (selection, in-training and certification). A Delphi methodology, which created a new training and assessment model for varying levels of trainees in General Surgery, rooted in previously set guidelines. A cross-sectional study, which demonstrated that staff surgeons are reliable assessors of trainee technical and non-technical performance. Finally, a multi-center cross-sectional study, which set performance standards for technical and non-technical performance, demonstrated a discrepancy in some traineesâ ability to meet both standards concurrently and examined factors that can predict standard (competence) acquisition. Conclusions: The findings contained within this thesis contribute evidence to the operationalization of competency-based assessments in General Surgery.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Peter Szasz
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2620560501
