Work

Motion perception deficit: risk factor or non-specific marker for neuro-developmental disorders?

Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: In their comprehensive review of motion perception in autistic spectrum disorder (ASD), Milne and colleagues (2005) mention both that deficits in motion perception are found in only a subset of autistic individuals, and that such deficits have also been evidenced in other neurodevelopmental disorders than ASD. I think that this point deserves further discussion. Indeed, it bears quite directly on the issue whether a motion perception deficit reflects an underlying cause of ASD or not. If it does, how can one explain that it is not present in all autistic children, and that it is present in children with other disorders but no autistic symptom? If it does not, why is it associated with ASD (and other developmental disorders)? Explaining this paradox requires a relatively sophisticated causal model. I will describe and discuss the respective merits of two classes of models that may serve this purpose: the multiple risk factor model and the non-specific marker model. The multiple risk factor model Given data on the prevalence of motion perception deficits both within the autistic and other populations, it must be concluded that a motion perception deficit (or the underlying dorsal visual stream dysfunction) is neither necessary nor sufficient to cause ASD, just as it is neither necessary nor sufficient to cause dyslexia or any other disorder (White, Frith et al., submitted). This quite directly excludes any theory of autism generally invoking a motion perception deficit as the underlying cause of ASD, in the classic sense of the
Source: HAL
Author: Franck Ramus
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2625951691
FWCI: 0.131
Cites: 24
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10