Work

Have Instrumental Variables Brought Us Closer to the Truth

Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: A survey of 255 papers that rely on the instrumental variable (IV) approach for identifying causal effects published in the “Big Three” finance journals reveals that IV estimates are larger than their corresponding uninstrumented estimates in about 80% of the studies, regardless of whether the potential endogeneity is expected to create a positive or negative bias based on economic reasoning. The magnitude of the IV estimates is, on average, nine times of that of the uninstrumented estimates even when economic insights do not suggest a downward bias of the latter. This study provides several explanations to the “implausibly large” IV estimates in finance research, and proposes best practices for identification-conscientious researchers. Received January 20, 2017; editorial decision April 7, 2017 by Editor Gregor Matvos
Author: Wei Jiang
Institution: Columbia University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2626039566
FWCI: 17.11
Cites: 8
Cited by: 545
Related to: 9