The Argumentative Turn Revisited. Public Policy as Communicative Practice Edited by FrankFischer and HerbertGottweisDurham, NC and London: Duke University Press, 2012. ISBN 978‐0‐8223‐5263‐1; £18.00 (pbk).
Year: 2013
Type: book-review
Abstract: The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning as a collection of articles that radicalized Majone's thesis that argumentation is the hard core of good policy analysis.In doing so, they posed a formidable postpositivist challenge to mainstream policy studies and policy analysis.Twenty years later, Frank Fischer and Herbert Gottweis edit the sequel, proudly harvesting the fruits of what stands now as a mature paradigm of argumentative or interpretive policy theory and analysis, inspiring a large body of work, both in the USA and Europe.Elaborating on themes in the 1993 book, the 2012 sequel features contributions inspired by discourse analysis, deliberative democracy, collaborative planning, frame analysis, discursive institutionalism, new media and film, rhetoric, narrativism, semiotics, post-structuralism, critical theory and transformative learning.In their introduction, Fischer and Gottweis clarify the meaning and relations among key concepts in their paradigm.Argumentation remains at the heart of policy-making; it draws on socio-cultural macro-discourses and institutions; but also encompasses other (meso-and micro-) modes of communicative practices such as rhetoric, deliberation, narration, expression of emotions, and images and pictures.In Chapter 1, Dryzek and Hendriks focus on structure and rules, participation and roles, and authority and design in the creation of more spaces and forums for deliberative democracy.In Chapter 2, Patsy Healy describes several cases of collaborative planning, showing how it depends not on specific techniques, but on a general attitude to planning processes characterized by an ethics of commitment, attention and transparent reasoning.Chapter 3 explains Vivien Schmidt's views on discursive institutionalism as a necessary complement to historical, economic and sociological institutionalisms.In Chapter 4, Mary Hawkesworth shows the usefulness of feminism-inspired frame analysis in deconstructing the discursive politics of development policy and globalization.In an original and excellent Chapter 5, Stephen Coleman discusses the internet as potential space for, but also threat to, authentic policy deliberation between citizens, experts and authorities: 'It may not be where policy is made . .., but it is increasingly the space in which it is shaped, announced, contested, and evaluated' (p.151).In Chapter 6, Sandercock and Attili narrate the making of their documentary, Toppan Best-set Premedia Limitedb s_bs_query
Source: Social Policy and Administration
DOI: 10.1111/spol.12033
Author: Robert Hoppe
Institution: University of Twente
Language: English
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: argumentative turn, policy analysis, communicative practices, deliberative democracy, collaborative planning, discursive institutionalism, frame analysis, rhetoric, narrativism, poststructuralism, critical theory, transformative learning, public policy discourse, discourse analysis, development policy, globalization
Open Access status: bronze
Awards: G6363285087, G8972648968
OpenAlex ID: W2155781126
