Numbers Are Not Everything.
Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: a big problem, especially, but not exclusively, in the sciences. During my first few years as a faculty member, salary increases in my department were based almost entirely on the number of pub lications and on whether one had external grant support. Most re search articles present minor, incremental contributions to a field, while just a few have significant impact?so why simply count? In my own field, theoretical physics, some ideas surface, are analyzed, and are then written up for publication within just a few weeks or less, so typical publication rates are quite high. In some experimen tal laboratories, by contrast, the construction of the apparatus can take several years. (In other laboratories, of course, the experiments are accomplished much more quickly.) Hence, there is a natural disparity in publication rates. Every scientist recognizes this counting problem, but administrators, who need to assess the relative merits of faculty, sometimes find it difficult to understand that numbers are not really adequate or criteria for evaluation. In many instances, the pressure to publish more articles is actually counterproductive. A junior faculty member striving for high numbers of publications might well be making the wrong investment in the prime of his or her career. In one case I know well, an individual published essentially the same research several times, disguising his misbehavior with different titles. The expression least publishable unit (nicknamed LPU) refers to one's ability to break up an extended research project into little pieces for the sake of a higher publication count. A scientist publishing LPUs will have many more publications than someone publishing more substantial articles, even though the integrated scientific content might be the same. Is this approach what we want to teach our graduate students? Is this situation not a reductio ad absurdum of the supposedly objective meaning of numbers?
Author: Milton W. Cole
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W269925184
