How can the experience of being on a community treatment order be understood in service user narratives
Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Introduction: Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) were introduced in the UK\nunder the Mental Health Act 2007. Recent data shows that CTOs have been\nemployed in far greater numbers than the government originally predicted, though\nevidence of their benefits remains limited. There has been considerable debate in\nthe research literature amongst professionals and service user groups about the\nethical concerns related to CTOs. In the light of this, it is important to study the\nexperience of being on a CTO. This study therefore aimed to explore the impact of\nthis with service users who were subject to CTOs.\nMethod: Six service users who had been on a CTO and were living in the\ncommunity were recruited from NHS services in England. The views of these\nservice users were explored in detail through individual interviews. Narrative\nanalysis was used to investigate how the service users described the impact of the\nCTO on their lives and relationships. Particular attention was paid to the influence\nof social and political context on these narratives.\nResults: Evidence from service users' narratives suggested that they generally held\nrelatively negative views about their experience of being on a CTO. Few described\nbenefits of the CTO and none felt their mental health had improved as a result.\nWhile some service users felt the CTO had had little impact on their relationships,\nothers reported damage to their relationships with professionals and expressed\nongoing anger about the CTO. Opposition to the CTO appeared to be mainly a\nresult of side effects of medication and fear of recall into hospital.\nDiscussion: Service users constructed their identities in relation to the dominant\nnarratives of the medical model, and the counter-narrative of the survivor movement.\nThis influenced their responses towards the CTO, with different forms of resistance\nand compliance noted. Implications of this for research and clinical practice are\ndiscussed.
Author: Oliver Pugh
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W272188935
