Work

Evidence-informed teaching : an evaluation of progress in England. Research report July 2017 (DFE- RR696).

Year: 2017
Type: report
Abstract: undertaking higher level academic study.There was some evidence from the interviews that teachers were feeling better equipped to engage with research over time.Most teachers valued research evidence.Whilst some teachers did not see the value of external research, most did, and this was influenced by:  The value placed on it by senior leaders and, crucially,  The need for such evidence to be problem-and practice-focused.Teachers trusted research evidence when it was supported by other evidence sources.Most teachers were unlikely to be convinced by research evidence on its own: they needed to have this backed up by observing impact themselves or hearing trusted colleagues discuss how it had improved their practice and outcomes for young people.External research evidence could challenge teachers' beliefs about their practice, but even in the most research-engaged schools such evidence was only seen to lead to sustained change in practice if there was time for informed debate and teachers to see the impact in practice. Conversations about decision-making in the more research-engaged schools included questions about research, typically: 'what does the evidence show'?Conversations about research were typically focused on practice-based problems, and how research evidence might contribute to dealing with them: the phrase 'the evidence shows that…' or questions like 'what does the evidence show?' were common in the most research-engaged schools.There was limited evidence from this study of teachers directly importing research findings to change their practice.Rather, research more typically informed their thinking and led -at least in the more engaged schools -to experimenting, testing out and trialling new approaches in more or less systematic ways.Organisational level KEY FINDING: The most strongly research-engaged schools were highly effective, well-led organisations within which 'research use' meant integrating research evidence into all aspects of their work as part of an ethos of continual improvement and reflection.In the most highly research-engaged schools, senior leaders played a key role, acting as intermediaries and facilitators of access to, engagement with and use of research evidence for staff in their schools.To do so, they often had direct access to research producers and were familiar with key intermediaries like the EEF, the work of John Hattie (Hattie, 2008) and other reviews such as the Cambridge Primary Review (Alexander and Armstrong, 2010).They were confident in judging the robustness of research quality.The most research-engaged schools started from a school priority and sought evidence to help meet this priority.This could be a school improvement priority or other problem.The most research-engaged leaders were able to synthesise the research evidence with other forms of evidence including school data and the experiences of other teachers and schools.In the less research-engaged schools, research evidence was often seen as a lower priority than other forms of evidence.This carried a risk that their decisions could be less effective than if they had considered all the relevant evidence.More research-engaged schools were leading or taking part in external research projects, and focused on collaborative research within and outside the school.Less research-engaged schools tended not to do this.Highly research-engaged schools supported evidence-informed risk-taking.They had reflective cultures, using research to inform Continuing Professional Development (CPD) and development-focused performance management.They created space to consider how this research could then inform practice.Evidence-informed risk-taking and experimentation (for example, in trying out new teaching techniques) was encouraged.Content analysis indicated that Teaching Schools were more engaged with research evidence than other schools, and this engagement was increasing over time.There was little evidence from the interview data of increased engagement with and use of research over the relatively short time period of the study, which was perhaps to be expected as the most engaged schools noted that strong engagement with research required long term strategic commitment.However, it is worth noting that Teaching Schools, overall, appeared -from the content analysis of school websites (see main report for detail) -to be more strongly engaged with research, and this was increasing over time.This contrasted with analysis of websites of other schools, in which they were less research-engaged and the picture was static. National level KEY FINDING: Senior school leaders felt government policy needed to be strongly aligned with research evidence.At a policy level, other policy organisations were judged to have stronger messaging than DfE.DfE documents promoting research use for school improvement focused on awareness of research and how to use evidence in school improvement.Other policy organisations (including EEF and NFER) produced more outputs in this area, according to the content analysis.The qualitative research indicated that teachers and school leaders were more likely to look towards the specialist organisations and academics rather than the DfE or its agencies.Government policy was seen to be more aligned with research evidence than in the past, but school leaders felt this needed to be improved especially in relation to accountability drivers.There was some evidence from the qualitative research that some  Support continued relevant research into effective evidence-informed practice. Consider ways of building on Teaching School leadership of evidence-informed practice in the system. Encourage senior school leaders to support evidence-informed teaching. Find ways to strengthen school-university partnerships, including in relation to Initial Teacher Training. Aim to embed research evidence in the professional discourse and practice of teaching. Aim to align policy changes with the best research evidence available.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2736852458
Cites: 6
Cited by: 14
Related to: 9