Work

Choosing boundaries for interventions: a study of environmental water management in the Murray-Darling Basin, Australia

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Any intervention aimed at improvement in a system involves boundary judgements on what is included and what is excluded from that system. A boundary judgement is a conceptual construct, defined for a specific purpose; it is intimately linked with judgements of knowledge and values that are considered relevant for the chosen purpose. This research focuses on the influence of boundary assumptions on approaches adopted for managing environmental water in the Murray-Darling Basin (MDB) located in south-eastern Australia. Two river catchments in the MDB—the Loddon River catchment in Victoria, and the Lachlan River catchment in NSW—were used as case studies to generate empirical data for in-depth analysis. Qualitative methods—field visits, semi-structured interviews with selected stakeholders, and document analysis—were used to identify boundary judgements of various stakeholders, in institutional arrangements and in scientific studies relevant to each case study. Narrow boundaries of ‘river health’ are assumed for active management of environmental water. However, ecological responses in complex and dynamic river systems rarely conform to the boundaries chosen for management. By prioritising a narrow set of ecological values and assets for active management, the interests of many people in non-priority sites and non-ecological values are marginalised. The research revealed that the misfit of boundaries is reinforced by an institutional culture that demands certainty and accountability, without acknowledging unavoidable uncertainties in dynamic river systems
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2741172093
Cites: 287
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10