Work

The emergency removal and safety placement of children at risk : a model for planning interventions

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Child abuse remains a major problem within communities, despite all efforts to date \nto try to intervene with children and families. There have been countless policies \ndrawn up which aim to protect children’s rights and prevent child abuse including the \nUnited Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, African Charter, South African \nConstitution, and the Children’s Act 38 of 2005. Some cases of severe abuse result \nin children being statutorily removed from their families in order to protect them from \nfurther abuse. Internationally, there are policies in place which guide professionals in \nhow to go about this emergency removal and safety placement of children at risk. \nHowever, within a South African context, this model for practice within emergency \nchild protection situations appears to be greatly lacking. \nWithout a model to guide social workers in these already difficult and challenging \nsituations, this leaves professionals separating children from their families without \nthe proper frameworks for practice. The removal of children from their families is \noften traumatic and devastating for the children, family, and even social work \nprofessionals involved; and this situation is further aggravated by the fact that \nprofessionals are not working from a standardised, evidence-informed, ethically \nbased, and theoretically founded practice model. \nThis study aimed to address this gap identified in literature and observed in practice \nby means of developing a model for planning interventions for the emergency \nremoval and safety placement of children at risk. Although emergency child \nprotection takes place immediately, it is important for professionals to be working \nfrom a structured intervention practice model which sets out the necessary strategic \ninterventions which need to be followed, to ensure effective services are rendered to \nchildren and families. \nv \nThe study utilised the design and development model of intervention research, \nconsisting of six phases. The first phase involved interviews and focus groups with \ndesignated and residential social workers and child and youth care workers, to \nexplore and describe the current intervention strategies used for the emergency \nremoval and safety placement of children at risk. The findings showed that there are \nmany challenges in the field of social work which are contributing to the poor \nservices received by children and families, which included: lack of supervision, no \nmulti-disciplinary team approach to services, limited infrastructure and a lack of \nresources, staff shortages and high caseloads. These challenges obstruct child \nprotection services, leading to an approach to child protection which is very rushed, \nchaotic, paperwork focused, and is deficient of an emotionally caring response \ntowards children and families involved. Results from the first phase of this study \nshowed that there was no practice model to guide social workers in how to remove \nchildren and place them in safety. As there is no practice model, and a gross lack of \nsupervision, participants from this study indicated that child protection practice is \ninstead guided by their gut instincts and cultural values. \nThe second phase of this study consisted of interviews and discussion groups with \nparticipants who provided information on various social work theories and how the \nbest interest of the child standard should be incorporated into a model for planning \nchild protection interventions. Significantly, the findings showed that the best interest \nof the child standard is not applied as a whole principle throughout the child \nprotection process, but rather in a fragmented way whereby bits and pieces of the \nstandard are used to justify specific actions. The findings from phase two highlighted \nthe need for an integrated and holistic approach to incorporating the best interest of \nthe child standard and social work theories throughout the child protection process. \nFor phase three, the researcher developed an observational system (after the model \nwas developed) as a means by which to observe and assess the implementation of \nthe model to provide further insights into its effectiveness. \nIn phases four and five, the knowledge, skills, and experience of designated social \nworkers, residential social workers and child and youth care workers were used to \ninform the development of the model. The participants provided information on \nintervention strategies, procedures involved with the emergency removal and safety \nplacement, and integrated the best interests of the child standard and social work \ntheories into the development of a model for planning interventions for the \nemergency removal and safety placement of children at risk. \nBased on all the data collected from the above-mentioned phases, as well as an indepth \nliterature study, phase five of this study involved the development of a model \nfor the emergency removal and safety placement of children. The model was \ndiscussed with and evaluated by social workers in the field of children protection as \nwell as a legal expert from the children’s court. Feedback obtained from the \nevaluations was used to adapt and finalise the model. \nPhase six consisted of the writing up of the research findings within three journal \narticles that will be submitted for publication in various academic journals. \nThe results of this study have addressed the gap identified in literature and practice by means of developing a model for planning interventions for the emergency \nremoval and safety placement of children at risk.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2746357099
Cites: 319
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10