Year: 2017
Type: book-review
Abstract: There are studies that transgress-methodically and creativelydisciplinary borders, enriching in a crucial way our understanding of major cultural, political, economic, and technological puzzles.The book How Not to Network a Nation: The Uneasy History of the Soviet Internet by Benjamin Peters achieves a complex epistemic goal that has, at the same time, deep moral, political, economic, cultural, and military ramifications.Peters resorts, in an efficient and elegant mode, to the tools of cultural anthropology, as happens with other landmark studies developed by Knorr-Cetina (1999) or Latour (1999).Peters' approach benefits from the expertise of an insider in a core Internet area: communication.The book explores the roots and consequences of the conflict between Internet and "Internyet" for the future of global communication.Peters' interdisciplinary exercise "in the emerging field of network studies, seeks to articulate a fluid discourse around the central term network" (p.9) and its Russian correspondent, set'.Resorting to a dialectical perspective, Peters explores the "uneasy history of the Soviet Internet" with genuine empathy toward the work of the Soviet scientists and their struggle to be creative within an ideologically closed and politically repressive system, while he accurately assesses that "the first global computer networks began among cooperative capitalists, not competing socialists [emphasis added]" (p.13).The first chapter investigates the "global history of cybernetics" (pp.15-17) within the confrontational context between the Soviet Union and the United States, between closed and open societies.Peters discusses the variety of sources and "synthesizing ideas" from philosophy, mathematics, engineering, biology and literary and social criticism that have been integrated by Norbert Wiener, credited with launching cybernetics.The historical inquiry shows that the genesis of cybernetics is the fruit of scientific creativity oriented toward highly abstract problems such as feedback processes and theory of messages combined with vital practical tasks, such as the design of antiaircraft fire-control systems, posed by World War II.The new field includes prominent contributors such as Von Neumann (game theory); Shannon (information theory); McCulloch (neurophysiology); Licklider (computer science); M. Mead; Bateson; Lazarsfeld; Lewin; the physicist Ampère, who coined the concept cybernétique; and the psychologist Odobleja.McCulloch's concept of "heterarchy" is discussed in contrast with hierarchy.The heterarchy reveals that "multiple competing regimes of evaluation" can emerge in all systems and "helps to describe some of the sources of conflict that beset Soviet cybernetics attempts to network their command
Author: Cătălin Mamali
Institution: Northeast Iowa Community College
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W2747000129
