Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: History is an important determinant of current economic development. One reason is cultural learning, which includes imitating behaviors from ancestors in order to save individual learning costs. Amongst anthropologists, there is widespread agreement that it is cultural learning that makes humans so adaptive in comparison to other species, which imitate less or worse. Nevertheless, culture also makes humans less adaptive than economists assume for the homo economicus (because humans imitate many behaviors without appraisal, inefficient behaviors might persist for a long time before they are changed). In this PhD research, much attention is focused on a cultural trait called self-efficacy. The concept has been developed by psychologist Albert Bandura and describes how much a person believes to have the ability to achieve self-chosen goals. Research has shown that self-efficacy affects which goals are chosen and how effectively they are pursued. Individuals with low self-efficacy in a domain either avoid it, or are unmotivated to invest sufficient effort, especially in the face of obstacles. The thesis begins with an investigation of whether colonial experiences persist to affect current contract farming performance in Ghana. During colonial times, the British government established cocoa export cooperatives and Christian missionaries established schools. The performance of the cocoa export cooperatives is found to have shaped the long term self-efficacy of the farmers in regard to the profitability of such global value chains and the Christian missionary schools persistently lowered village level social capital. Thus, historically rooted cultural differences currently explain the performance of contract farming in different communities. Even earlier causes of divergent cultures are the experiences with pre-industrial subsistence farming systems. Where the biogeography incentivized cereal farming, farmers were rewarded for agricultural investments and thus developed self-efficacy regarding agricultural investments. Where the biogeography incentivized other farming systems based on roots, tubers, or tree crops, investments were less rewarding and farmers developed lower investment self-efficacy. These differences are found to significantly explain income differences amongst Ghana’s current pineapple farmers. The causal channel are investments, which are critical for the profitability of pineapple and which are determined by the farmers’ investment self-efficacy. A special feature of self-efficacy is furthermore, how people react to adversity. Whereas high self-efficacy leads people to increase their efforts after failure, low self-efficacy leads to decreased efforts. It is found that farmers with high self-efficacy are able to mitigate a significant share of lost income from droughts. The reason is that they are more likely to adopt a climate smart innovation that conserves water when rainfall decreases. Their peers with low self-efficacy are not found to adapt. Investing which farmers achieve higher incomes than predicted by ancestral’ experiences, it is the well known variables education and social capital. Thus, overcoming history is not found to require special policies, at least for the pineapple farmers in Ghana. Agricultural trainings about innovations are also a potential policy tool to increase rural incomes in Ghana. However, a significant effect is only found for more complex innovations, whereas simpler innovations can easily be learned from other farmers. Globally, a very different relationship between culture and economics is investigated. Attempting to explain why not all World Heritage sites are promoted as such, it is found that site and regional specific, economic variables explain the pattern well – whereas constraints and the collective benefit do not matter much. To strengthen the brand, it is thus either necessary to help more sites to benefit, or to make promotion mandatory.
Author: David Johannes Wüpper
Institution: Technical University of Munich
Language: English
Subfield: Development
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2747016479
