Work

Being Consistent With Reality: a Great Challenge for Chemistry Laboratory Reports

Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: The experimental component has fundamental roles in chemists' training, and laboratory reports provide evidence of critical aspects of students' understanding.This paper focuses on a crucial understanding and interpretation aspect: students' awareness of the nature, details and scope of the phenomena observed and their ability to distinguish them from apparently related descriptions available in textbooks or on the internet.A study of laboratory reports for physical chemistry experiments across several years highlights a variety of statements included in reports and having nothing to do with the given experiment.The causes range from passive acceptance of pre-learnt paradigms, for which a student writes the same set of pieces whichever the nature of the experiment, to lack of confidence in one's writing ability and consequent passive borrowing of sentences, patterns and entire sections from other sources, and to poor attention to the details of the experiment in question or actual failure to understand it.The paper considers examples from different components of laboratory reports, analyses the dichotomies between what students write and what could be called the 'reality' of the experiment, and outlines approaches to attract students' attention to the importance of 'sticking to reality' in the description and interpretation of experimental work.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2747955425
FWCI:
Cites: 13
Cited by: 4
Related to: 10