Work

The Health Gap: The Challenge of an Unequal World: the argument

Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: In early 2015, the US city of Baltimore erupted. The precipitant of the eruption was the killing of a Black man in police custody; actually, one more killing of a Black man by police.1 But the underlying cause was inequality in social and economic conditions. It was not the whole of Baltimore that erupted – leafy Roland Park was riot-free–but the deprived inner city. Between the district with rioting and the best-off district, Roland Park, there is a 20-year gap in male life expectancy. I wrote about the Baltimore life expectancy differences in The Health Gap.2 Although the unrest had not yet happened, it is no surprise that riots broke out in the area with worst health. Life chances are so much worse. It is unlikely that ill health is causing riots or that civil unrest is driving a 20-year gap in life expectancy. More likely, social and economic conditions shape the lives people are able to lead, and these in turn lead to inequalities in health and the likelihood of civil unrest. I describe the social determinants of health as the conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work and age; and inequities in power, money and resources that give rise to inequities in the conditions of daily life. How these social determinants lead to huge inequalities in health within and between countries, and what we can do about them, are the substance of The Health Gap. I slipped inequalities ‘between countries’ into the previous sentence. The Health Gap deals with inequalities between, as well as within, countries for three reasons. First, it gives us perspective. A 20-year gap in life expectancy seen in Baltimore, Glasgow or the London Borough of Westminster is enormous. It is as big as the gap between women in India and women in the USA. It shows us the scale of inequalities that we are dealing with. Second, and increasingly, the health problems of middle-income countries are similar to those of high-income countries: non-communicable disease and external causes of death. It means that the causes that are relevant in one country are likely to be relevant in another. It means, further, that we can learn from experiences in different countries. If you are reading this in Canada, experience in Chile or Cuba may be relevant; if in Rio, so may Reykjavik. Middle-income countries are also characterized by a growing proportion of elderly. In low-income countries there is the additional burden of communicable disease, to which social determinants of health are highly relevant. Third, if the question is why some countries have better health than others, social determinants of health provide an important part of the answer. Such determinants may operate within a country but also may act at a global level: trade, financial flows, treaties and overseas development assistance. In response to the question–which is more important for health, absolute or relative poverty––I answer: both. It is instructive to contrast LeShawn growing up in the deprived Upton Druid district of Baltimore with Bobby, growing up in Roland Park. LeShawn’s was a single-parent family, like half the others in Upton/Druid Heights. Their household income in 2010 was $17 000, the median for the neighbourhood. At school, in common with four out of ten of his classmates, he scored under the ‘proficient’ mark in reading in the third grade; and in high school he was one of the more than half of his neighbourhood who had missed at least 20 days of school a year. LeShawn completed high school, but like 90% of his neighbourhood, he did not go on to college. Each year in Upton/Druid Heights, a third of youngsters aged 10 to 17 were arrested for some ‘juvenile disorder’. A third every year means that there is little chance that LeShawn would get to the age of 17 without a criminal record, with everything that means for the future. In Upton/Druid, in the period 2005 to 2009, there were 100 non-fatal shootings for every 10 000 residents, and nearly 40 homicides. The contrast with Bobby in Roland Park is stark. Bobby, and all but 7% of his neighbours, grew up in two-parent families, median income $90 000. Bobby was one of the 97% of his neighbourhood to achieve ‘proficient or advanced’ in the third grade reading. He was not among the 8% who missed at least 20 days a year of high school, and he was one of the three-quarters who completed college. When it comes to juvenile arrests, there are no guarantees of immunity, but the figure for Roland Park is one in 50 each year, compared with the one in three in Upton/Druid. Another stark contrast with Upton/Druid: there were no non-fatal shootings in 2005–09, and four homicides per 10 000 – one-10th of the Upton/Druid rate. Writing from England, I cannot help but comment that had guns not been freely available, there would have been far fewer non-fatal shootings and homicides in either area. Deprivation leads to crime, but without ready access to guns, at least your violent behaviour toward your neighbours does not end up with someone getting shot. I have ignored the fact that the population of Upton/Druid is almost exclusively Black and that of Roland Park nearly uniformly White. The determinants of health, and crime are not Blackness or Whiteness, but accumulation of disadvantage through the life course. The perspective of the ‘causes of the causes’ recognizes that advantage and disadvantage are, in the USA, closely linked with race, largely because of widespread and institutional discrimination. These case histories help with the question of absolute versus relative poverty if we put another contrast into the mix: India. Average income per person in India at the time I was writing about Baltimore was $3 300 adjusting for purchasing power. Yet male life expectancy in India is nearly 2 years longer than in Upton Druid. The poor of Baltimore are fantastically rich compared with the average Indian but have worse health. The poor of Baltimore are deprived relative to the standards prevailing in Baltimore. This might sound as though I am coming down on the side of relative rather than absolute poverty, except that lack of money really matters to LeShawn’s mother. Lack of money influences diet, shelter, neighbourhood, the kind of care she is able to give to LeShawn, the stress she and he are under. My resolution of apparently having it both ways comes from following Amartya Sen.3 Relative inequality with respect to income translates into absolute inequality with respect to capabilities. It is not so much what you have but what you can do with what you have. Being relatively low-income in a society where good child services are available to all, quality of schools is not dependent on the wealth of the neighbourhood, medical care is free at the point of use, public transport is available and subsidized, affordable housing is available in mixed neighbourhoods–think Norway–will be very different from being relatively low-income in a society that lacks these–think Upton Druid. Sen speaks of having the freedom to lead a life one has reason to value. I use the term empowerment. LeShawn is disempowered in ways that matter to his health: not just relatively to Bobby, but absolutely. A disrupted childhood and living in poverty will have adverse impact on early child development. Consequent poor school performance reduces life chances in occupation, income and living conditions. A social environment that is discriminatory and fosters crime will do little for social integration. Given all of this, healthy lifestyle choices are low priority. The discussion of absolute and relative poverty is highly relevant to the social gradient in health. In the Whitehall studies of British Civil Servants, with men and women classified by grade of employment, the higher the status the better the health and the longer the life expectancy. Other studies, particularly in the USA, show a gradient by years of education–more years of education, better health. Figure 1 in The Health Gap comes from the Marmot Review4 of health inequalities in England. It shows gradients in life expectancy and disability-free life expectancy according to degrees of deprivation of area of residence. Life expectancy and disability-free life expectancy (DFLE) at birth: England 1999–2003. Source: The Marmot Review (ONS).5 The gradient is important both for explanation and for policy. It is difficult to imagine that degrees of absolute deprivation account for the worse health and shorter life expectancy of people near the top, compared with those at the very top. In Sweden, for example, people with PhDs had lower mortality than those with Masters degrees or with professional qualifications. Such differences cannot be attributed to degrees of absolute deprivation in any usual sense of that word. It may relate to how relative position translates into social and psychosocial conditions. In other words, LeShawn in Baltimore is at the end of a spectrum of disadvantage, not on a different spectrum. The scientific challenge, then, is to understand why inequalities in health run from top to bottom of the social hierarchy, and how that understanding applies to inequalities in health between countries. The Health Gap brings together evidence across the life course from individuals, communities and whole societies as to how that plays out. For policy, the gradient is equally profound. It engages all of us. Ill health of the poor can excite prejudice: the poor are the architects of their own misfortune; worrying about them only encourages fecklessness. If of a different political persuasion, we might think that it is wrong that we organize affairs such that the poor suffer ill health, but at least we are not so affected. The gradient gives the lie to both of these. In England, people in the ‘middle’ of the social hierarchy will, on average, have 7 fewer years of healthy life than if they were at the top. Driving home this point, in the USA the average is not healthy. The probability that a 15-year-old boy will die before his 60th birthday ranks higher than in 49 other countries. That this should be a matter of public concern was emphasized by the recent paper by Case and Deaton,6 which showed a rise in mortality rates among US Whites (non-Hispanic) aged 45–54. The fewer the years of education, the steeper the rise, thus making the social gradient steeper. Much as we are all concerned about diet and other behaviours, this was not a lifestyle issue. The causes of the rise in mortality of these 45–54 year olds were poisonings due to drugs and alcohol, suicide and chronic liver disease–presumably linked to alcohol. I describe this as disempowerment on a grand scale. Certainly it is neither an issue of lifestyle nor of medical care. The gradient involves all of us. Inequalities in social and economic conditions through the life course are responsible for many inequalities in health. When we look at early child development, for example, we see a social gradient. I draw the parallel with Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, in which there were five castes. The Alphas and Betas were allowed to develop normally. The Gammas, Deltas and Epsilons were treated with chemicals to arrest their development intellectually and physically. The result: a neatly stratified society with intellectual function, and physical development, correlated with caste. Should we, as in Huxley’s dystopia, tolerate a state of affairs that stratifies people, then makes it harder for the lower orders, but helps the higher orders, to reach their full potential? Were we to find a chemical in the water, or in food, that was damaging children’s growth and their brains worldwide, and thus their intellectual development and control of emotions, we would clamour for immediate action. Remove the chemical and allow all our children to flourish, not only the Alphas and Betas. Yet, unwittingly perhaps, we do tolerate such a state of affairs. The pollutant is poverty or, more generally, lower rank in the social hierarchy, and it limits children’s intellectual and social development. The social gradient in readiness for school, as with attitudes to poverty and health, is a political litmus test. People on the right tend to blame poor parenting. Those on the left say it is social disadvantage. I say they are both correct. Social and economic conditions influence parenting. In fact, when we plot proportion of children aged 5 years who are classified as ready for school, against deprivation of a local authority in England, we see two patterns. First is the gradient: the more deprived the local authority, the smaller the proportion of children aged 5 years with a good level of development. Second, there is scatter around the line: for a given level of deprivation, some local authorities are doing better than others. These two patterns suggest two strategies for improving early child development: reduce poverty, and support parents and families. Figure 2 (Figure 4.4 from The Health Gap) shows what is possible in reducing child poverty. Romania, the USA and Latvia have similar levels of child poverty before and after taxes and transfers. The Nordic countries, The Netherlands and Slovenia are among countries that use the tax and benefit system to achieve low levels of child poverty. Other things equal, low levels of child poverty will be associated with better early child development–measures on which the Nordic countries and The Netherlands do well. Child poverty rates before taxes and transfers (market income) and after taxes and transfers (disposable income). Source: Innocenti Research Centre.7 The complementary approach is to create high quality services to support families. In the Nordic countries, with state-subsidized child care, the people who work in these services are highly trained professionals. There have also been several interventions for early childhood that have been evaluated and do indeed improve the quality of early child development. High quality early child development sets the agenda for everything that follows: better educational performance, better job, higher income, better living conditions and, as a result, better health. We see that countries that invest in pre-school have higher performance in schools, as assessed by scores on maths and literacy in the Programme on International Student Assessment (PISA). An example of how a life course approach to adult health may play out is provided by comparison of countries in Latin America. Cuba, Costa Rica and Chile have high proportions of children enrolled in pre-school and have high reading scores on standard tests at school. At the other end of the scale, Paraguay, the Dominican Republic and Colombia have low enrolment in pre-school and less good reading scores. I note that Cuba, Costa Rica and Chile have the life expectancy among these Paraguay, Dominican Republic and Colombia the Such comparison is of but it is with a life course better early child development, better educational performance, better health in adult life. The discussion on the lack of quality and other on There is another to think about on children’s development: the things that can A in was the Child People were their years of they had any of three of childhood put down or or in of physical and about being into were also about four of household someone they with a or of or suicide of a household treated criminal behaviour in the People to that which does not us makes us It It makes us more likely to get those who no adverse experiences as the compared with them, the more different of adverse experience a person the the of and People who had four or more different of adverse childhood experience had nearly five the of having 2 or more in the previous year, and the of having In the more of adverse childhood the more likely people were to describe as to have to have had 50 or more the more adverse the higher the of chronic disease or and The was not a A of studies that child physical and did not are linked to adult suicide use, and from the half the adult of had been as more half the had been as child experiences have a reach and they are more lower down the social thus to the social gradient in adult and physical health. societies have social and economic If health were linked with position on the social hierarchy, then health inequalities would be they are, but the of the the of the This is by a comparison of countries in the Figure (Figure from The Health Life expectancy at age in countries by level International Social of where to lower and Source: In for example, average life expectancy for men at age is only more 10 years fewer than men with the level of have life expectancy 17 years fewer than for men with the level of compared with In Sweden, the average is higher and the gap in life expectancy between the least and is about 17 as in we see in other the differences are smaller for women than for In all the countries with the inequalities in life expectancy are in and are the countries of the with income, and they also tend to be those with the average life expectancy. But we see for those who think that our health is by the choices we If you are to have the level of education, you would be well to have it in Sweden, or rather than in or it the other if you have the level of education, it really matters which country you For those with the level of education, it matters far I this It is a of People have no control where they are born, and only some control how much they Another of at the is that the differences in life expectancy between countries are much smaller for people with and much for those with only I have emphasized the life course. It is likely that is an important of adult mortality for two of First, fosters life that will be important in different Second, is correlated with other things in adult life that are to better health: job, income, of and relative freedom from This is the likely explanation for the gap in and compared with and Being poor in is associated with a good less deprivation than being poor in the makes it is not all when children school. life and do indeed people on a But what age and at life important to health In The Health I on and income and I to up the question of and in The that income inequality the health of is correlated with average health of a I find the in Figure to be a more the lower the position in the hierarchy, the more health is by living in a country with poor average health. The fact that the poor suffer more does not income inequality the Inequalities of income may have on health in at least three what do the people of the 7 people of Paraguay, the 2 people of Latvia and the US have in all have income of The that inequalities of income and wealth can lead to health inequalities is that if the rich have so there is less available for I do not imagine that has in the to a to but if they did they would as they would their the it would This improve the health of in two a and improve the public Such money for and provide and a countries, if some people have others may have If to and the top that people living in the of or the of London have little for a healthy the system has In the USA it has been that almost all the income growth between 2010 and of to the top At the of the population were in an for and of poverty as less than of the median income, after taxes and transfers. in and with much lower levels of income of the population are in poverty, the living in a rich some people do not have to lead a healthy that the for Second, if much of the money is being at the top, local and may have little to on pre-school education, schools, improving services and for two what in and public is a good of such show that there is a of money of the income of the top like New Third, much inequality of income and wealth social the rich are from schools, Lack of social is likely to health and We to that what was good for was good for America. it It is a good harder to the case that what is good for or or and the who lead them, is good for America. I to the The of and up with the of The I not give a such a I The of the but a I I the The of and the inequalities in health within and between countries. I then together the evidence on what we can do through the life course to reduce inequalities in with in early child development, education, conditions and better conditions for I the The of because I from the that show we can a Such can be at local in and at level and We have evidence to of
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,514
OpenAlex ID: W2750976723
FWCI: 9.603
Cites: 13
Cited by: 257
Related to: 9