Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: The introduction of a risk-based approach for the management of floods has particularly triggered a stronger involvement of flood vulnerability with its exposure as element of risk generation complementary to the flood hazard as well as a focus on the probabilities of flood events with their impacts as a means of determining the reliability of flood defences and tolerability of risk. With risk defined as the likelihood of negative consequences, areas with a (potential) risk, such as settlements, moved to the fore (cf. EU Floods Directive). Risk reduction strategies accordingly concentrate on the control and conveyance of discharge from upstream of these areas at risk and the protection of the vulnerable elements. These strategies involve a high degree of grey infrastructure, such as upstream dams and local defences, in combination with technologies for flood proofing of constructions. Recently, experts from nature conservation emphasised the meaning of natural processes for nature conservation and natural resources management (International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), 2012). This led to the concept of so-called nature-based solutions (NBSs) which in the meantime has been also set on the politically agenda (e.g. Nesshöver et al., 2016) not least since it fits well the broader context of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. NBSs have been defined by the European Expert Group on ‘Nature-Based Solutions and Re-Naturing Cities’ as ‘… actions inspired by, supported by or copied from nature; both using and enhancing existing solutions to challenges, as well as exploring more novel solutions, for example, mimicking how non-human organisms and communities cope with environmental extremes. nature-based solutions use the features and complex system processes of nature, such as its ability to store carbon and regulate water flows …’ (European Commission (EC), 2015, p. 24). Additional criteria for the definition of NBSs have been proposed by Albert et al. (2017). In principle, the concept seems to have a relation to water and flood issues and hence asks for consideration in the disaster risk community in general and the flood risk management community in particular. Both observations and model-based analyses carried out at catchment scale indicate that the larger the catchment and the higher the severity of an event, the lower are effects of the land surface on the discharge and resulting floods (e.g. Rogger et al., 2017). However, it is also expected that NBSs may exceed the influence of land cover and could have more significant hydrological or hydrodynamic effects, especially if realised in a spatially densely distributed manner. Direct effects are supposed to be complemented by indirect effects on other ecosystem services and landscape functions and hence require comprehensive assessment disclosing co-benefits. Therefore, it is crucial to examine carefully the potential of NBSs as a contribution to flood risk management rather than adopting the term as a buzzword only. Exploration of this potential seems to be additionally justified given the remaining high flood risks in many regions of the world (e.g. Tanoue et al., 2016) and the limitations of existing design levels of grey infrastructures under the conditions of climate and societal change. Advancements of understanding could be grounded in a few guiding questions for flood risk management science and practice and their joint efforts with nature conservation and natural resources management. First, what do NBSs actually mean in terms of flood risk reduction? Its answer is likely to need a closer look at the mechanisms of nature retaining, infiltrating, storing, and dissipating water flows. This closer look should involve analysis with high spatial and temporal resolution, on different scales and for the diversity of environmental conditions. Second, how to design NBSs in an ecosystem-based and sustainable manner? Its answer comprises a wide scope of alternative design principles from nature conservation to soft-engineering and necessitates experiments for standardisation, performance control, and replicability. Third, how to allocate NBSs on a large scale under specific natural and societal conditions? Its answer demands the upscaling of NBSs from experiments to the scale of river networks and catchments and of coastlines including the combination of NBS portfolios. Furthermore, it necessitates comprehensive impact assessment with a component of comparison with traditional risk reduction measures and instruments, also considering co-benefits. Fourth, how to participatory design and implement NBS portfolios? Its answer calls on pre-requisites for cultural and social acceptance and economic feasibility as well as on uncovering barriers and enablers resulting from the governance context, such as property rights and market mechanisms. Fifth, how to mainstream NBSs? Its answer is closely related to the potential contributions of advanced planning and management practices, institutional contexts, market uptake with possible financial instruments, and capacity development. Moreover, it calls for an incremental development based on learning from performance control and societal experience. From the aforementioned questions and the proposed focus for their answers, it is obvious that innovation regarding NBSs requires the involvement of flood risk management science and practice, but also of stakeholders from a multitude of sectors relevant for NBS implementation, local communities, and landowners. Science is supposed to focus on advancement of NBS design principles, standardisation, upscaling, and impact assessment with the respective methods and modelling strategies. Flood risk management practitioners may contribute with their local knowledge and comprehensive experience and establish links to nature conservation practice. Stakeholders are key for cultural and social acceptance, economic feasibility, and handling of institutional barriers and enablers. Thus, collaboration of these parties should build on co-design, co-deployment, and co-evaluation of NBSs and include mutual learning (e.g. Mauser et al., 2013). There is a long tradition of observation of natural processes in view of flood risk reduction and in water management in general. This led to multiple attempts to build with nature in the recent past. However, these attempts have often been carried out with the sectoral focus on water. Moreover, findings from certain sites, small field plots or water laboratories are not always upscalable to river networks and catchments and to coastlines. Field studies are especially challenging in terms of standardisation and thus cause limitations referring to replicability and transferability to other regions. Performance of NBSs in laboratory experiments cannot be easily upscaled and comprehensively assessed under real-world conditions. Therefore, the effectiveness and acceptance of NBSs for flood risk reduction on a large scale to a certain degree are still unknown and lack well-documented experience. As a consequence, NBSs so far can hardly be sufficiently considered in flood risk management and compared with other technical solutions. Against this background, there is an urgent demand to enhance efforts on advancing knowledge on and practical experience in NBS implementation in flood risk management. To do so, the following key tasks should be of high priority: (1) to strengthen documentation and standardisation of NBSs through experiments; (2) to develop and test methods and tools for upscaling and combining NBSs, participatory planning and comparison with hard-engineering works; (3) to analyse and advance the institutional context including planning systems, market mechanisms, and capacities to facilitate mainstreaming of NBSs for flood risk reduction. Findings and experiences from that should be treated in an unprepossessed way to avoid misinterpretation and underperformance during real events. Based on the previous studies on NBS experiments, it may be expected that they are likely to play complementary, integral roles in flood risk reduction strategies. These roles need to be more clearly understood, measureable, and implementable considering regional natural and societal conditions. In addition, co-benefits should be made tangible, such as effects on the reduction of risks from other natural hazards, but also on nature conservation and natural resources management. All in all, the brief look at NBSs from the viewpoint of flood risk management suggests that the relatively new concept seems to be worthwhile for further consideration in both science and practice. Not at least as the need for a close cooperation between various scientific disciplines and multiple sectoral and local stakeholders seems to open up some room for joint innovation.
Source: Journal of Flood Risk Management
DOI: 10.1111/jfr3.12318
Author: Jochen Schanze
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: nature-based solutions, flood risk management, flood vulnerability, flood hazard, flood control, grey infrastructure, catchment size, land cover, hydrological impacts, nature conservation, EU Floods Directive, 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, disaster risk reduction, flood proofing
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2751367778
