Work

A Task Analysis of how Clients Formulate Reappraisals in Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for Depression

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The generation of adaptive appraisals of self are theorized to play a key role in the effective treatment of depression in cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT), yet there are few descriptive analyses of clients' in-session behavior during dysfunctional appraisal tasks. The primary objectives of this investigation were to develop a model to describe how clients resolve a dysfunctional appraisal task in CBT for depression (Rice Greenberg, 1984), and to examine the relationship between higher degrees of resolution of a dysfunctional appraisal, and good outcomes in psychotherapy. A task analysis was used to develop and test a model of resolution of dysfunctional appraisals. In the first phase, a rational model of the expected sequence of client processes was developed from a review of relevant literature. An empirical model was then derived by comparing resolved and non-resolved events within 13 transcripts from archival data of a CBT for clinical depression treatment (Goodridge Hardy, 2009). The rational and empirical models were synthesized. The sequence of components described by this model are: the Dysfunctional Appraisal task marker, Elaboration, Accessing Vulnerability, Shift: Softening and/or Shifting Perspective, Evaluating New Perspective, and Reappraising (task resolution). In the second phase, the validity of the model was examined. A measurement tool, the Degrees of Resolution Scale of a Dysfunctional Appraisal task (DRS-DA), was created. The DRS-DA is an observer-rated 7-point measure representing the presence of the components of the derived model. Higher ratings on the DRS-DA indicate higher degrees of resolution of the dysfunctional appraisal task. To investigate the relationship between the model and outcome, 22 transcripts were used from archival data of a CBT for clinical depression treatment (Watson et al., 2003). Results demonstrated that there was a relationship between DRS-DA score and post-session change. Moreover, DRS-DA scores differentiated between good and poor outcome clients, and good outcome clients were more likely to demonstrate Evaluating New Perspective in their highest reported change sessions than poor outcome clients. This study provides preliminary support for the model.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2755047234
Cites: 188
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10