Work

Socioeconomic consequences of early-onset psychiatric disorders, mental illness and stress in a life course perspective

Year: 2000
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Data from a representative community sample of 1393 Toronto residents aged 18-55 who were surveyed in the early 1990s show that the high prevalence of disorders, particularly early-onset disorders, merits the consideration of mental illness and substance use disorders as significant new predictors within the traditional socioeconomic status attainment framework. The prevalence level of such disorders in the Toronto study is corroborated with findings from other psychiatric epidemiological surveys of general populations in the US and Canada. For as long as sociologists and psychiatric epidemiologists have observed associations between mental illness and socioeconomic status, two competing explanations have been proposed: social selection and social causation. Both arguments imply a process that develops over time, but empirical studies from either perspective typically do not model the data correspondingly. This dissertation approaches this problem from an integrated standpoint that is informed by life course theory. The analysis does not statistically test the competing theories, because I argue that they are not necessarily incompatible. Processes of social causation and social selection 'both' operate over developmental time. The results largely attest to the utility of an integrated perspective to improve understanding of the role of mental illness in socioeconomic status attainment. Analyses involving several socioeconomic outcomes show that the integrated approach is fruitful. Most types of early-onset disorder negatively impact socioeconomic achievement. Results vary across types of disorder and the particular socioeconomic outcome measure, and in some cases findings are contingent on gender. While the measures used in this study are entirely retrospective, it is argued that the present data are not inferior to those of the latest prospective studies on this subject. Specifically, it is better to have lifetime rather than only recent information on the experience of disorders in order to make valid inferences about their causes and consequences because disorders are typically enduring, whether persistent or recurrent.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2760101334
Cites: 42
Cited by:
Related to: 10