Work

Rethinking Recognition : Transnational Families and Belonging in Law

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation investigates how transnational family relationships come to assume legal character, how and for what purposes ‘legality’ is invoked; and analyses the ways in which the recognition of transnational family relationships generate belonging or non-belonging and how these belongings are constructed in legal practice and argumentation. Finally, it explores whether recognition theory might offer grounds for rethinking social justice in relation to transnational families. It traverses three fields of law: family law, private international law and migration law. The dissertation examines the research subject at four different sites: Muslim marriage practices in Finland; religion, culture and the concept of gender equality within the framework of The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW); legislation in the Nordic countries on family reunification; and selected court cases on family reunification from the Supreme instances in Finland and Sweden, and the European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice. At each site, research material differs and consequently different methodologies are applied, but the overall theoretical framework of the dissertation is socio-legal; feminist intersectionality in particular is used as an analytical approach. The dissertation consists of six articles that from different perspectives examine the ways in which transnational families are recognised and regulated in law. Article I, ‘Between “official” and “unofficial”: Discourses and practices of Muslim marriages in Finland’, draws on qualitative data from interviews with imams and other staff in eight Helsinki-based mosques, individuals, and bureaucrats; and cases collected from four local register offices and three district courts. It traces the ‘legality’ of Muslim marriages in mosques, practices of selected individual Muslims, and state institutions concerned with the registration and validity of marriages. Article II, ‘CEDAW and the Riddle of Diversity: Can Culture, Traditions or Religion Justify Economic Inequalities Embedded in Family Laws?’, focuses on the issue of culture and human rights law through a discussion of the concept of equality underpinning the CEDAW Convention. Article III, ‘Ruling on belonging: transnational marriages in Nordic immigration laws,’ examines the immigration regimes concerning marriage migration in the Nordic countries, all of which have introduced considerable restrictions on family reunification in their Aliens Acts in recent years. Article IV, ‘The “nuclear family paradigm” as a marker of rights and belonging in transnational families,’ and Article V, ‘The married child belongs to no one? Legal recognition of forced marriages and child marriages in the reuniting of families,’ argue that by invoking the discourses of status and relationship, the tensions and intersections of different legal fields are controlled, all the while the image of unitary law is maintained. Article VI, ‘Best interests of the child in family reunification - a citizenship test disguised?’ examines how the rights of the child become paradoxical when applied as part of the proportionality assessment used for the purposes of family reunification, and how a non-belonging identity is actively constructed for a citizen-child in the argumentation of the case. The dissertation adds to the studies on transnationalism and develops the notion of intersectionality from the specific perspective of legal research.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2761660157
Cites: 114
Cited by: 11
Related to: 10