A Connectionist Investigtion of Linguistic Arguments from the Poverty of the Stimulus: Learning the Unlearnable
Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: Based on the apparent paucity of input, and the nonobvious nature of linguistic generalizations, Chomskyan linguists assume an innate body of linguistically detailed knowledge, known as Universal Grammar (UG), and attribute to it principles required to account for those "properties of language that can reasonably be supposed not to have been learned" (Chomsky, 1975).A definitive account of learnability is lacking, but is implicit in examples of the application of the logic.Our research demonstrates, however, that important statistical properties of the input have been overlooked, resulting in UG being credited for properties which are demonstrably learnable; in contradiction to Chomsky's celebrated argument for the innateness of structure-dependence (e.g.Chomsky, 1975), a simple recurrent network (Elman, 1990), given input modelled on child-directed speech, is shown to learn the structure of relative clauses, and to generalize that structure to subject position in aux-questions.The result demonstrates that before a property of language can reasonably be supposed not to have been learned, it is necessary to give greater consideration to the indirect positive evidence in the data and that connectionism can be invaluable to linguists in that respect.
Authors: Lewis, John D., Elman, Jeffery L.
Institution: University of California San Diego
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2767487109
