Semiosis Beyond Culture: An ecological approach
Year: 2015
Type: article
Abstract: SECTIONCULTURE Fall 2015 ASA Meeting 2015 From the Invited Panel “Culture and its Intersections”: Cultural Sociological Intersections and Informings: Art, Literature, Philosophy Semiosis Beyond Culture: An Ecologi- cal Approach Robin Wagner-Pacifici, The New School Fernando Dominguez Rubio, UC San Diego For this year’s ASA conference, we were invi- ted to participate in the panel “Culture and its Intersections” with the specific remit of reflec- ting on the future of the discipline through its intersection with other fields of inquiry. What follows is a version of the paper I presented at the conference, which revolved around the idea that, if cultural sociology is to maintain its rele- vance today, it needs to move beyond the idea of “culture”. Admittedly, this may sound a little bit outlandish, to say the least. For, what is cultural sociology if it is not the study of culture? My an- swer to this question is that cultural sociology should be understood, instead, as the study of what we could call, following Charles Peirce (1955: 282–5), “semiosis”, that is, the study of the generation of meaning. What I want to argue in this brief note is that the study of semiosis—i.e. the study of how mea- ning is generated—has been unduly constrained by what I would like to call the “cultural view”. By this I mean that view according to which be- liefs, values, norms, etc., are linked to one ano- ther constituting a more or less coherent and au- tonomous system, called “culture”, which is said to live in people’s minds and bodies in the form of, among other things, mental schemata, lingui- stic systems, or bodily dispositions. Following this view, the mission of cultural sociology has been understood to be that of providing a causal explanation accounting for how “culture”, thus understood, shapes how we act, how we think, and how we communicate. The problem with this cultural view, I want to argue, is that it provides us with a very I start, as so much of sociology does, with a puzzle. What are events? How do they take sha- pe? Why are they so riveting and repulsive at the same time (drawing our fascinated attention and making us queasy)? Events highlight the age-old existential and sociological issue of the relation- ship between continuity and change, but they seem to do so in specific ways. Having a puzzle I had to figure out how to investigate it, how to trace the phenomenon. Everything is or can be data in this endeavor and myriad ways exist to interrogate them. Ac- tor-Network theorist Michel Callon calls the pro- cess of locating and following “data” translation or free association; Bruno Latour terms it a relay race; but I think of it more as tracking — follo- wing sociological intuitions and electrical char- ges as events move through one informing after another. Which brings me to a large disciplinary question: how can sociologists best investigate things like events, things that both take shape and move? One approach is to think about the nature of eventful infusions, the way that events move th- rough many forms on their aspirational ways to coherence or sedimentation. This shares much with a processual approach, but with a differen- ce. Process and structure are both in the picture. This is where art, literature, and philosophy (among other media and modalities of commu- nication and expression) come in — each deals with form and flow in its own ways. Sociologists, especially sociologists of culture, can make it their business to know these forms and their ca- pacities — can try to know them from the inside asaculturesection.org
Author: Fernando Domínguez Rubio
Language: English
Subfield: Literature and Literary Theory
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2767575245
