Work

Using social norms in energy conservation interventions

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: When designing interventions to promote pro-environmental behaviors, practitioners may\nchoose between techniques based on, for example, education, incentives, or social norms.\nThese intervention techniques may, however, target different kinds of motivation, and\ntherefore differ in their psychological and behavioral implications. The aim of this thesis is to\nassess norm-based intervention techniques targeting energy conservation.\nStudy I compared a contest-based with a norm-based intervention technique. In two online\nexperiments participants performed pro-environmental tasks (writing energy-saving tips and\nfictive recycling) while provided with either normative or competitive feedback. Results\nshowed that participants assigned to the contest-based intervention technique engaged more\nintensively in both tasks. Participants in the norm-based intervention technique showed a\ntendency for stronger intention for future energy conservation and stronger activation of\npersonal norms for non-targeted pro-environmental behaviors.\nStudy II applied the findings from Study I in two field experiments. Participants were\nrandomly assigned to a norm-based or a contest-based intervention targeting electricity\nconservation. In the contest, both experiments confirmed an intensive but short-lived effect of\nelectricity conservation. Experiment 1 confirmed increase electricity saving attitudes and\nmore long-term electricity conservation in the norm-based interventions. Results of\nExperiment 2 did not replicate these findings, but supported a positive spillover effect\nbetween electricity and water conservation only in the norm-based intervention.\nStudy III tested a conceptual development of the descriptive norm. Analogous to the\nseparation between injunctive proscriptive and prescriptive norms, we suggest that the\ndescriptive norm can be separated into signaling others’ engagement (a descriptive “donorm”)\nor disengagement (a descriptive “don’t-norm”). In line with our hypothesis that don’tnorms\nare more influential, results from three experiments consistently showed that don’tnorms\noutperformed do-norms (15%, 10% and 19%). However, only the third experiment\nsupported the difference with statistical significance.\nStudy IV examined compliance to prescriptive and proscriptive norms, targeting energy\nconservation. In a 2 (words: prescription vs. proscription) × 2 (picture: prescription vs.\nproscription) between-subject design, participants were exposed to prompts promoting\nenergy-saving. Results supported the hypothesis, showing that more participants (88.1%)\nconformed to prompts including both prescriptive and proscriptive content than to prompts\nincluding either prescriptions or proscriptions (78.6%). A follow-up experiment indicated that\nthese results were driven by attention and reactance. Finally, when asked which prompt\nparticipants would use to influence other people to act pro-environmentally, the majority of\nparticipants (80.1%) chose the prompt that was least effective in our field experiment.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2771983892
Cites: 204
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10