Work

Big Data and Personalized Price Discrimination in EU Competition Law

Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: The networked digital revolution is ushering in a new data-driven age, powered by the engine of Big Data.1 We generate a massive volume of digital data in our everyday lives via our online interactions, which can now be tracked on a continuous and highly granular basis. This tracking ability, combined with the power of machine learning algorithms, has given rise to a wide and varied range of ‘personalized’ services, ranging from personalized news content, advertising, energy management, fitness measurement and management, street navigation through to dating and mating services. These technologies have radically disrupted the retail sector, following the founding of digital retailer Amazon in July 1994 by entrepreneur Jeff Bezos, which is now valued at $US373 billion. Amazon’s success, and the reason why customers return to it time and time again, is due to its ability to improve the shopping experience, whether through predicting what stocks to keep, understanding consumers’ preferences and recommending other, complementary products, etc. to its collation, interpretation, and utilization of Big Data to personalize our digital shopping experience. However, this digital personalization is no longer limited to shopping recommendations and advertising delivered to our smartphones, laptops, and other mobile devices, but may extend to the prices at which goods and services are offered to customers in online environments, making it possible for two individuals to be offered exactly the same product, at precisely the same time, but at different prices, based on an algorithmic assessment of each shopper’s predicted willingness to pay. For example, in 2000, Amazon.com sold DVDs to different people for different prices, prompting a public outcry that resulted in Amazon claiming it was merely a test and refunding the price difference to people who paid more. Yet in 2012, an Oregon newspaper reported that consumers were again finding that the prices charged for items on Amazon.com were highly variable, with one consumer placing a set of mahjong tiles in her shopping basket offered at a price for $54.99, but a few minutes later, found that the price of the item in her basket had jumped to $79.99, and when she cleared the cart and tried again, the item was then priced at $59.99. In the same year, a Wall Street Journal investigation found that Staples Inc.’s website displays different prices to people after estimating their locations. If rival stores were physically located within approximately 20 miles from that person’s estimated location, Staples.com usually showed a discounted price; a 2015 study into price differences in international travel bookings for US hotel and car rental, showed a similar pattern.2 These instances all mine consumers’ digital footprints, using machine learning algorithms to enable digital retailers to predict the price that individual consumers (‘final end users’) are willing to pay for particular items, and thus offer them different prices. This phenomenon, which we dub ‘algorithmic consumer price discrimination’ (ACPD) forms the focus of this paper.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2774287759
FWCI: 27.76
Cites: 45
Cited by: 85
Related to: 10