Metal-phytoextraction: potential of high biomass energy crops and improving efficiency using short rotation coppice (SRC) of willow
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In the northeast of Belgium (the Campine region), an area of at least 280 km2\nis\nhistorically contaminated with mainly cadmium (Cd), zinc (Zn) and lead (Pb).\nThe negative impacts on inhabitants and the environment in general as well as\neconomic losses in the farming industry urged regional policy makers to strongly\nrecommend the remediation of the metal-contaminated soil. Given the vastness\nof the area and the diffuseness, moderation and shallowness of the\ncontamination, phytoextraction, i.e. the use of plants to extract metals out of\nthe soil and accumulate them in harvestable biomass, is proposed as a good\nremediation strategy. More specifically, cultivating non-food high biomass crops\nwith moderate metal accumulation capacity reveals promising for this area.\nIn this thesis, different high biomass species were cultivated and evaluated for\nseveral years in field trials on a Cd-Zn-Pb-contaminated soil in the northeast of\nBelgium to investigate which high biomass crop exposed the highest, but also\nthe most stable (in time) phytoextraction potential on these soils. Biomass\nproduction and metal accumulation of pre-selected tobacco clones (Nicotiana\ntabacum L.), pre-selected sunflower mutants (Helianthus annuus L.) and a\ncommercial hemp (Cannabis sativa L.) were determined for 2-4 subsequent\nyears while the phytoextraction potentials of more than 200 different\ncommercially available and experimental (designed by the Institute of Nature\nand Forest; INBO) poplar (Populus) and willow (Salix) clones in short rotation\ncoppice (SRC) were assessed at the end of the first cutting cycle (after 4\ngrowing seasons). The tobacco clones and the sunflower mutants revealed to be\nefficient extractors of respectively Cd and Zn, while the highest, simultaneous\nextraction of Cd and Zn was observed using the woody species in SRC.\nPhytoextraction of Pb appeared to be utopia using the evaluated crops but this is\nnot considered a major problem given the low bioavailability and activity of Pb.\nThe estimated long remediation times (> 60 years) furthermore indicated that\ncrosscuts with economic and (other) environmental advantages are crucial for\nlarge-scale implementation of metal phytoextraction. When for the evaluated\ncrops these external benefits, assessed by reviewing literature, were combined\nwith the observed phytoextraction potentials, SRC revealed to be the most suitable crop for the implementation of metal phytoextraction in the area under\ninvestigation.\nIn parallel with the field evaluations of the high biomass crops, metal\nphytoextraction using SRC of willow was studied into more detail in this\nresearch. SRC of willow is a high biomass crop abundantly investigated in the\nframework of metal phytoextraction. However, the longer-term effectiveness of\nSRC phytoextraction applications is rather unknown due to the complex\ninteractions between, and evolutions of the main entities of a phytoextraction\nsystem. Therefore, determining effective reduction of metal levels in soil and\nchanges in soil toxicity, and also soil fertility and functionality, in longer-term\nfield experiments with SRC phytoextraction applications is of high importance.\nThe SRC experimental field in the metal-contaminated area in northeast Belgium\noffers a unique opportunity to this concern. Pseudo-total soil metal\nconcentrations and soil toxicity, estimated using standardized chemical\nextractions and plant- and invertebrate-based ecotoxicity assays, were assessed\nin soil managed by 8 years of metal phytoextraction using SRC of willow (Tora;\nSalix schwerinnii x Salix viminalis) and in soil without phytoextraction\nmanagement. The observed decontamination might indicate a much more\neffective phytoextraction (48 times in case of Cd removal, 79 times for Zn\nremoval) by 8 years of willow-management than predicted by extrapolating\nmetal removal of Tora after 4 growing seasons. Furthermore, the chemical\nextractions and all ecotoxicity tests unanimously indicated the willow-managed\nsoil to be less toxic, to different extents, compared to the unmanaged soil. The\nresults all emphasize the environmental benefits of a SRC-phytoextractionmanaged soil compared to no management.\nTo reduce remediation times of metal phytoextraction using SRC of willow\nand/or increase benefits of phytoextraction synergies, a last part of this research\nfocused on improving willow biomass production and/or metal accumulation. A\nselection of 3 strategies was proposed to meet this concern: in situ clone\nselection, bioaugmentation of willow with beneficial plant-associated bacteria\nand fertilization of willow. The in situ evaluation of clones, performed on the SRC\nexperimental field in the metal-contaminated area, lead to the selection of 2 experimental (INBO) willow clones, Salix viminalis and Salix alba x alba. In\ncomparison with the best performing commercial and other experimental clones,\nthese clones exposed by nature higher stem metal concentrations (up to 7% for\nCd and 21% for Zn) (S. viminalis) or a higher biomass production (up to 4%)\n(S. alba x alba). Bioaugmentation of the previously selected willow clones,\nevaluated in pot experiments with in total 17 promising bacterial strains, did not\nresult in improved biomass yields nor enhanced metal accumulation or\ntranslocation. The fertilizer applications on the contrary, also applied to the\nformer selected willow clones growing in pots, raised productivity levels\nsignificantly and in case of S. alba x alba, in planta metal concentrations also\nincreased. As a result, the tested fertilizers doubled (S. viminalis) or even tripled\n(S. alba x alba) phytoextraction efficiency of the selected clones.\nIn conclusion, of all evaluated high biomass crops for metal phytoextraction in\nthe Campine area, a prominent role is reserved for SRC. Focusing on metal\nphytoextraction in this region using SRC of willow, the decontamination rate\nobserved on the longer term revealed to be much higher than previously\npredicted. Moreover, in situ clone selection and adjusted fertilization applications\nseem very promising strategies to further reduce remediation time using this\ncrop.\nFinally, our results demonstrate that it is highly recommendable to perform\nfuture research on phytoextraction topics as much as possible in situ.
Author: JANSSEN, Jolien
Language: English
Topic: Heavy metals in environment
Subfield: Pollution
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDGs: Life on land, Zero hunger
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2775513259
