Work

A Critical race feminist perspective on Section 217 of the Constitution

Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Section 217 of the Constitution of South Africa regulates the procurement of goods and \nor services by any organ of state. Similarly, this section mandates state-owned \ninstitutions to adhere to a procurement system that promotes groups that were \npreviously disadvantaged by past colonial and apartheid regimes. In this dissertation I \nargue that due to South Africa’s oppressive culture, the law has been ineffective in \npromoting the socio economic interests of black women due to race, gender and class \nsubjugation. \nFirstly, central to my argument is the judiciary’s traditional role that is still steeped in an \ninterpretative process of the law that is detrimental to the transformative spirit of the \nConstitution. In identifying the South African judiciary system as positivistic in nature I \nwill critically analyse the Sonke Gender Justice Network v Malema hate speech court \ncase. I posit that the Equality Court’s decision was mainly result based and as a result \nfell short of addressing the core issues affecting black women on the basis of race, \ngender and class which mirror the substantial part of the South African socio economic \nstructure. Secondly, in support of my argument, I criticise a legislative framework that \nperpetuates socio economic disparities at the expense of a group in society it claims to \nprotect. Whilst I will rely on American Legal Realism and Critical Legal Studies in \nsupport of my arguments, my main theoretical approach will be based on Critical Race \nFeminism. Lastly, intersectionality will be used in contextualising the interrelationships \nof race, gender and class as they impact on black women’s material circumstances in \nthe regulatory legislative public procurement process. \nWhen the Constitution came into effect in 1994 South Africa became an egalitarian \nstate. Nevertheless, the country is struggling with the prevalence of unemployment, \npoverty, HIV/Aids, skills shortages, male violence including rape, to name just a few. \nThese social ills pose a threat to a Constitution that extolls values like dignity, freedom \nand equality for all. It so happens also that the majority of the people confronted by \nthese socio economic challenges are black women. The tender process faces numerous challenges and by identifying the South African \nculture as oppressive supported by a legal process that stifles transformation, this study \nexpounds the experiences of black women by engaging in a contextual analysis of the \ncourts and legislation. This consciousness raising exercise is not meant to portray black \nwomen as victims or invoking “special treatment” in the legal realm. It resonates with \nSteve Biko’s theme of black consciousness, being aware of the marginalisation and \naddressing it. Black consciousness represents an emancipatory state and optimistic \noutlook. Consciousness raising situates the oppression of black women in any form as a site for struggle, a struggle for social and individual change.
Author: Pamela Nyawo
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W277569018
Cites: 29
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10