Work

A Study on Privacy Trading:the Trading Between Personal Information and Monetary Incentives

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis focuses on a problem that how service providers exchange between consumers' personal information and monetary incentives, it aims to increase consumers' disclosure of personal information without increasing monetary incentives.The willingness to disclose personal information follows a complex process and each person values his or her personal attributes differently.Decisions as to whether or not to disclose personal information can be organized as a network structure.This thesis proposes a method to evaluate personal information using consumers' attitudes regarding personal attribute disclosure.The proposed method is used for our experiment by ordering the requested personal attributes.This thesis develops new knowledge to quantitatively increase the disclosure of personal information without increasing monetary incentives.Previous related works adopted many approaches such as auction and survey to assess the value of personal attributes; however, their results were only valid for specific situations.An adaptive approach is proposed here for more general situations.Although this case study selected Thai people as samples, by changing samples, this approach remains valid in a variety of situations such as in specific countries or within certain age ranges.Moreover, previous related works did not consider the dependency of personal attributes, whereas our thesis addresses the correlation of personal attributes from a more general approach, they can be considered as special cases under our approach.The thesis consists of six chapters.Chapter 1 describes the background, problems, objectives, scope, limitations, preliminary definitions, and proposes study contribution.Chapter 2 outlines previous literature regarding the definition of personal information, privacy issues, problems concerning data collection, and assesses the valuation methods and notions of personal attribute monetary incentive trading.Chapter 3 compares the different viewpoints and trading angles between consumers and service providers.The collected data from Chapter 3 forms the datasets for Chapters 4 and 5. vii Chapter 4 proposes a non-monetary valuation method for personal attributes.A graph is constructed based on Bayes' formula and analysed through graph mining techniques to determine relationships among personal attributes.Graph edges are used to compare values between each pair of personal attributes.Our graph proves robust within the evaluation context but encounters problems applying results in the absence of numerical values.Chapter 5 outlines the development of an application to conduct an experiment on the trading of personal information using monetary incentives.We propose a new technique to calculate the constructed graph into numerical values termed Value of Unwillingness to Disclose (VD).Personal attribute that contains high VD means consumers want to protect this personal attribute more than other personal attributes that contain lower VD.We then invite consumers who were separated into three groups to complete our evaluation.Each group is asked to decide their trade between personal attributes and prepares monetary incentives.The order of personal information by VD is arranged differently for each group as top-down from highest VD to lowest VD, bottom-up from lowest VD to highest VD, and adaptive ordered by consumer profiles.Results indicate that it is possible to motivate consumers to disclose personal information without increasing monetary incentives.Participants disclose more personal data when the trading application requests personal attributes based on participant profiles.Chapter 6 summarizes the results and limitations and postulates directions for further research.Our proposed approach can be used in different environments and for diverse groups of consumers; however, limitations and conditions are encountered during the study.To investigate personal information demands, we choose 212 top ranking global websites as our samples.Data regarding consumers' attitudes when disclosing personal attributes are collected from samples with similar perspectives toward personal information disclosure.Data are compiled from 532 Thai Internet users since the Internet and social media activity in the country rank amongst the highest in Asia.These datasets are incorporated into our proposed valuation method and 160 Thai participants are invited to complete the experiment.The proposed method of using personal attribute values to rank the order of personal information requests focuses on the negotiation mechanisms used on trading platform environments.The knowledge created on the ordering of personal attributes can be used to improve the exchange of personal information through monetary incentive activities, such as requesting personal information in a survey and the creation of online questionnaires.viii Currently, Thailand does not have any specific statutory law governing data protection or privacy; however, the government is in the process of drafting the Personal Data Protection Act.The findings from this study including personal attributes clustering, consumers' attitudes toward personal information, and ordering of personal information may be useful for organizations, and also relevant to the drafting of this Act in the areas of personal information categorization and personal data inquiry.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2782682189
Cites: 30
Cited by:
Related to: 9