Work

Anxiety and dependence to Media and Technology Use: media technology use and attitudes, and personality variables in Portuguese adolescents

Year: 2016
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This study examined the relationships between anxiety/dependence of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) involving the frequency of and attitudes towards its use and personality dimensions in a sample of Portuguese adolescents.The sample consisted of 322 subjects aged between 12 and 18 years.The Portuguese version of the scale Use and Attitudes towards Information and Communication Technologies (MTUAS-PY; Costa, Matos, Pinheiro, Salvador, Dias & Zenha-Rela, 2016) and the Ten-Item Personality Inventory (TIPI, Gosling, Rentfrow, & Swann Jr., 2003) were used.The results showed that individuals with high anxiety/dependency had higher averages in several ICT use indicators (emailing, social networking, etc.), attributed more importance to ICT, scored higher in the simultaneous execution of multiple tasks, and presented lower scores in the personality dimensions of emotional stability and consciousness.We can conclude that anxiety/dependence relates to the use and attitudes towards ICT as well as with personality variables. Explanatory hypothesesHuang (2010, 2012), in literature reviews, identified a debate as to whether the effect of Internet use on psychological well-being is beneficial (augmentation hypothesis) or detrimental (displacement hypothesis).The augmentation hypothesis suggested that the association was positive since the Internet use for communication provides a context for social interaction and interpersonal development, thus improving the user's psychological well-being.The displacement hypothesis indicated that the association between Internet use and well-being was negative, because Internet use for communication replaces face-to-face interaction or real-life interaction.According to Huang (2010Huang ( , 2012)), in the literature reviewed, the findings about Internet use and psychological well-being were diverse.This author added that in two previous meta-analyses and in his meta-analysis with 40 studies about well-being (e.g., loneliness, depression, self-esteem, and life satisfaction), a relationship between Internet use and psychological well-being was not found.An emphasis was given to the need to ameliorate the measurement instruments of social networking use and the complexity of the studies (e.g., moderator effects should be studied).Nie and Hillygus (2002, 2009) proposed the time-displacement hypothesis, asserting that the use of the Internet implies a reduction, in a non-work context, of the time spent in direct contact with friends and family.It seems that, if on the one hand, the use of online communication could somehow encourage the development of online friendships, increase feelings of self-esteem and social support, on the other hand, it is associated with greater social isolation in real life, and lower quantity and quality of face-to-face friendships, implying a greater risk of online exploitation (Gapsiso & Wilson 2015;Wolak, Mitchell, & Finkelhor, 2003).Other authors claimed that communicating with others on the Internet via text messages allows preventing certain unpleasant aspects of social interactions while partially meeting the needs for personal contact and belonging (Erwin, et al. 2004).Desjarlais and Willoughby (2010), in a longitudinal study of adolescents, examined support for the social compensation and rich-get-richer hypotheses, including social anxiety as a moderating factor.The social compensation hypothesis suggests that adolescents with high levels of social anxiety may report more positive friendship quality if they use computers with friends or on line communication than other adolescents who also have high social anxiety but do not use ICT to compensate for their social anxiety.This was suggested to occur because computer-based interactions may create a more comfortable social situation for socially anxious adolescents in comparison to traditional face-to-face interaction.The rich-get-richer hypothesis proposes that subjects who are already comfortable in social situations can use ICT to look for additional opportunities for socialization, with the aim being talking on the phone, or in person.Results showed that, among girls, the main effect of using computers with friends or online communication on friendship quality was positive, providing support for both hypotheses.For boys, social anxiety moderated this relation, supporting the social compensation hypothesis.More recently, Kardefelt-Winther (2014a) provided a compensation theory that explains excessive Internet use without framing the behavior as pathological and considers the importance of motives.This author hypothesized that excessive Internet use may be a coping strategy to deal with life stress, driven by the necessity to escape real life problems and/or reduce negative moods, i.e., a strategy originated in the confluence of stressful life situations and the ubiquitous availability of Internet.This hypothesis of a coping strategy rather than a compulsive behavior could help explain why some people keep spending so much time online despite experiencing negative outcomes.Positive and negative outcomes were pointed out: an individual feels better because he gets the desired social stimulation but he may not go out and make new offline friends, which in the long run means he could become dependent on the Internet for social stimulation.According to Kardefelt-Winther (2014a), "this scenario would be labelled as an Internet addiction when approached through a pathological perspective" (p.352).This author also suggested that studies to test this theory should move away from a focus on direct effects models and consider mediation and interaction effects between psychosocial well-being and motivations in the context of Internet addiction.In a study on online playing (World of Warcraft game), with 702 players from 14 to 60 years, Kardefelt-Winther (2014b) studied previously identified aspects as relevant for gaming: social anxiety, loneliness and stress, and motivations such as success, escape, and social interaction.The results showed that stress is the most important aspect, giving empirical support to the compensatory model.The results also revealed that although loneliness and social anxiety were correlated with excessive use, they lost significance when stress was controlled for.Furthermore, all psychological predictors lost significance when escapism and achievement were controlled for "upon entering motivations in the model all psychological characteristics lost significance" (p.211).Higher levels of stress were associated with negative outcomes of play, but this was an indirect effect explained by the escapism motivation.The author concluded that these results suggested that the effect of psychological characteristics on negative outcomes was indirect, i.e., mediated by motivations.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2787765296
FWCI: 2.975
Cites: 75
Cited by: 12
Related to: 10