The Law of 2009 concerning the selling and serving of alcohol to youths: from state of the art to assessment (ALCOLAW)
Year: 2018
Type: report
Abstract: The Law of 2009 concerning the selling and serving of alcohol to youths: from state of the art to assessment -ALCOLAW Federal Research Programme Drugs 121.1 Effectiveness of the minimum legal drinking age Research designsThe extensive research on the significant correlation between alcohol consumption and potential negative outcomes was discussed in the introduction of this report.Data showcasing this correlation is of limited value however when determining the exact impact of the minimum legal drinking age.This is due to two main limitations: firstly, the correlation between alcohol consumption and negative consequences is hypothesized to be at least partly due to other factors, such as individual variation in risk tolerance.This implies that people with a high risk tolerance are more likely to put themselves in risky situations, even when they are not drinking.Moreover, MLDA legislation is likely to have a disproportionate effect among the most law-abiding citizens.Both cases can cause significant, upward bias; hence there is a need for direct estimates of the effect of the drinking age on alcohol consumption and alcohol-related outcomes.In order to gain a valid estimation of the effect of MLDA legislation, the alcohol consumption patterns and outcomes of adolescents, subjected to the law, should be compared to those of adolescents not subjected to it.To achieve valid results, it is of great importance that the test and control group are very similar in all aspects other than their subjection to the law.Over the years, researchers have applied two main research designs to do this (Carpenter & Dobkin, 2011b).A first design, called panel approach, is to investigate consumption patterns before and after a change in legislation, or between similar areas with different MLDA legislation.In Belgium, the minimum age changed in 2009.So, one may expect that adolescents aged 15-18 right before the law was changed, grew up in different circumstances as those aged 15-18 right after 2009 -when the MLDA legislation was changed.Similarly, a large body of research has accumulated between 1960 and 2000 from MLDA changes in the United States (see section 3.2.1.).The panel approach is a good means of investigating the effects of a changed MLDA, with its major advantage being that it provides the most direct measure.Despite this clear advantage, several limitations pose a threat to the validity of this approach.One potential limitation is that of confounding factors.In cases where multiple policies targeting alcohol consumption and its adverse consequences are implemented simultaneously, a panel approach will likely overstate the true effect of the MLDA.In the case of US legislation, this concern was voiced by several authors, such as Miron and Tetelbaum (2009).Closely related is the drawback that a panel approach only offers a meaningful result as long as other societal factors remain relatively stable.MLDA legislation in the United States was altered over 30 years ago.Since then, many factors such as enforcement, public norms and car safety may have changed.These changes can bias the panel estimation results in different directions.A final threat to validity is the 'learning from experience effect'.If adverse consequences of alcohol use are inherent to people who start consuming alcohol, regardless of age, the effect of a changed MLDA will be overstated since alcohol-related problems will merely shift to a different age group.So far, very few studies have looked into this hypothesis, but the available research does not seem to support the claim that the effect exists (Carpenter & Dobkin, 2011b;Conover & Scrimgeour, 2013).Project DR/00/071 -The Law of 2009 concerning the selling and serving of alcohol to youths: from state of the art to assessment -ALCOLAW Federal Research Programme Drugs 13A second research design applies to any given period of time when a minimum age is in place.Since the MLDA functions as a discrete cut-off point, this design compares people who are just under the minimum age with those who are just over.Both groups are likely to be similar, except for their subjection to the MLDA.A disproportionate increase in alcohol consumption or alcohol-related outcomes would indicate that the MLDA legislation is an effective means to curb underage drinking.This design is called the regression discontinuity method and was first applied by Thistlethwaite and Campbell (1960) as an alternative to the ex-post-facto experiment.This quasi-experimental approach can provide credible estimates of the causal effect of an intervention on a specific outcome.Compared to the panel approach, a regression discontinuity design has fewer limitations that threaten validity.Apart from the learning effect, the most significant drawback is that any estimation is only valid for people very near the MLDA.If a change in minimum legal drinking age affects people who are substantially younger or older than the MLDA, this information will be lost through the regression discontinuity design. Research overview United StatesA large body of research on the effectiveness of the minimum legal drinking age has accumulated over the past few decades.The vast majority of this research was conducted in the United States.After the end of prohibition in 1933, all US states enacted a minimum legal drinking age, with most states opting for age 21 as the legal limit.Age limits remained unchanged until the Vietnam era.Social distress during this period caused many states to decrease the minimum age for privileges of adulthood including the voting age, the legal age of consent and also the minimum legal drinking age.From 1970 to 1975, 29 states decided to lower their MLDA, setting the age limit at ages 18, 19 or 20 (Wagenaar, 1993).The years after these decreases were marked by a significant rise in alcohol sales, consumption and alcohol-involved traffic fatalities among underage people in the involved states, as was shown by a plethora of studies (Cook & Tauchen, 1984;Ferreira & Sicherman, 1976; US Government Accountability Office, 1987).On the basis of these consequences, supported by statistically sound research, several states once more increased their MLDA, eventually leading up to the introduction of the National Minimum Drinking Age Act in 1984, through which the federal government sought to harmonize all states' MLDA legislation to set 21 as the nationwide minimum age.By 1988 all states Project DR/00/071 -The Law of 2009 concerning the selling and serving of alcohol to youths: from state of the art to assessment -ALCOLAW Federal Research Programme Drugs 20 Anderson, P., Møller, L., & Galea, G. (2012).Alcohol in the European Union.Geneva, Switzerland:
Institution: University of Liège
Language: English
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2788787968
