Fracture management in Malawi: Patients´ and professionals´ experiences with skeletal traction. “The patients are more or less like prisoners in the hospital ward.”
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background: Traumatic injuries represent a growing portion of the global burden of disease (GBD), implying death and disability for millions of persons. Injuries cause an unmet need for trauma care, treatment and rehabilitation, in particular in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC). This study explored patients´ and professionals´ experiences with lower limb fracture management by skeletal traction in Malawi. This method has been obsolete in high-income countries for decades, yet a substantial number of patients sustaining fractures in LMIC are still treated with skeletal traction. The method necessitates long-term immobilization in the hospital bed, in most cases between eight to twelve weeks. Method: Data collection was performed during a ten-week-fieldwork in Malawi. Data were collected at the two largest public hospitals in the country, Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital (QECH) in Blantyre and Kamuzu Central Hospital (KCH) in Lilongwe respectively. To provide a holistic evidence base about the topic, an explorative case-study approach triangulating methods and informants was chosen. This implied participant observation, eight interviews with patients, two multidisciplinary focus group discussions, and individual interviews with two surgeons and a physiotherapist. Findings: The study demonstrates that patients experienced physical and psychological pain and discomfort from prolonged bed rest, anxiety about future prospects, indignity and emotional distress from the ward environment and little influence on treatment and decisionmaking. Patients also emphasized the negative impact on guardians and families, and significant economic consequences to households due to prolonged hospital admission. The combination of long admission and cut-off of income generating activities appeared to push less resourced families further into poverty. After discharge from the hospital, informants experienced persistent disability that enforced dependency on others, unpredictable living situations and economic problems. Professionals, on their side, experienced major obstacles in providing quality treatment due to lack of trained personnel, lack of materials and equipment, and lack of specialized knowledge and skills. The outcomes of conservative skeletal traction were considered substandard to modern surgical treatment, but scarce resources allegedly provided no option. Important identified factors to improve fracture management were listed to be multidisciplinary teamwork, enhanced specialized knowledge and skills, readily available equipment, evaluating the methods used and developing standardized procedures for future fracture management. Introducing the Perkins regime of traction that allows more active treatment was also considered to be one step in the right direction. Physiotherapy and rehabilitation services were identified to be nearly absent, thus efforts to maintain function and enhance recovery during and after long-term bed confinement were at a minimum. Professionals also pointed at the economic burden to the health system following prolonged hospital admission. Conclusion: The use of obsolete methods in a low-resource setting inflicts devastating impact on patients and their families, and causes major frustrations to professionals involved with fracture management.
Author: Lise Haug
Language: English
Subfield: Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: skeletal traction, lower limb fractures, fracture treatment, patient experience, health professionals' experiences, prolonged bed rest, psychological distress, family financial burden, poverty, multidisciplinary teamwork, health workforce shortage, low- and middle-income countries, Malawi, trauma care, ward environment, patient decision-making
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2791956679
