Argumentative activities: a pedagogical tool to help grade 5 students classify geometric shapes by their properties
Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Some international surveys have reported that although Taiwanese primary students were ranked above nearly all other countries in mathematics achievement, their competences of geometry and reasoning performed were relatively poor.Geometric shapes have complex relationships with their properties, and primary students tend to use their intuition and what they see to discuss these relationships.This leads students to make mistakes easily.For this reason, this research developed an argumentative activity to help Taiwanese primary students improve their geometric thinking and reasoning.The participants in this research were 168 grade 5 students in Taiwan, and these students were divided into three groups; two experimental groups (EXP_1 and EXP_2) and one control group.All students did a geometric argumentation test (GAT) twice as the pre-and post-test.The control group only did these two tests.Students in both experimental groups undertook sorting tasks where they classified triangle shapes along with argumentative activities, but they experienced different teaching strategies.Both groups experienced the "why-and how-questions" but students in the first experimental group also experienced 40 minutes of comparison strategy in argumentative activities.In the sorting tasks of classifying triangle shapes in argumentative activities (STCTAA), students in EXP_1 and EXP_2 had to classify different kinds of triangle shapes and generalize what triangle properties were important to help them classify.This research found several points.There were two cognitive competences in the GAT, which were designated "naming geometric shapes" and "geometric thinking".Using the comparison strategy with the why-and how-questions could monitor students' thinking and reasoning, and manipulating or measuring geometric shapes was also important for learning geometric shapes.The comparison strategy showed its effect directly in students' behavior, but there was no significant effect on the GAT results.The two teaching strategies that were implements could be used in the classroom settings for primary teachers in Taiwan.The research also provides some suggestions for primary teachers, and mathematics education researchers.A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.This proverb could describe my studying journey for my Ph.D. study.I withdrew my first Ph.D. degree in Taiwan because of my research interest.When I applied my applications to many universities, my principle supervisor, Prof. Kaye Stacey, kept contacting me and gave me some critical suggestions to revise my proposal.Prof. Kaye's attitude impressed me and attracted me to do research with
Author: Tsu-Nan Lee
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2794765897
