Work

Bread Losers: An investigation on the effects of employment status and socioeconomic status on male gender role conflict and depressive symptoms

Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Research in the study of men and masculinity has often focused on the amount of psychological distress generated by the dissonance between the perceived ideals of manhood and the self-perceived adherence to the male normative role (David & Brannon, 1976; Pleck, 1981). This concept has been named gender role conflict (O’Neil, 1986). The current study investigated how this conflict is related to the depressive symptoms, and whether these symptoms are exacerbated when a man who perceives himself as a breadwinner (primary financial provider for his family) has difficulty meeting this obligation due to loss of employment. It also investigated the relationship between the experience of this conflict and the level of traditional male gender role endorsement as a function of socioeconomic status. \nAdherence to traditional male gender role norms was assessed using the Male Role Norms Inventory Revised (MNRI-R) developed by Levant and colleagues (2007). The dissonance between these norms and how the participant sees himself was measured by the Gender Role Conflict Scales (GRCS) developed by O’Neil (2008). Depressive symptomatology was measured using the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) (Radloff, 1977). \nThese measures, along with demographic information, employment status information and socioeconomic status self-report items composed a 132-item questionnaire completed in a traditional “paper and pencil” format. All responses were collected in vivo. Data was collected from the community at various settings including auto repair shops, a medical clinic, a bus station, a barber shop, and a mall in Lubbock, Texas. Eighty-three men completed a sufficient amount of the study for their responses to be analyzed. Participants were compensated with an entry in a drawing for one of three gift certificates to a local retailer. Approval was secured from Texas Tech University’s Institutional Review Board. \nA two-way ANOVA was employed to look for a main effect of breadwinner status and employment status on CES-D scores and GRCS scores. A significant interaction was found between breadwinner status and employment status in the prediction on depressive symptoms. Thus, men who were unemployed experienced more depressive symptoms on average if they also identified as breadwinners. A regression was used to investigate the relationship between adherence to traditional male gender roles (via MNRI-R) and depressive symptoms in unemployed men. MRNI-R score did not moderate the relationship between employment status and depressive symptoms, nor the relationship between depressive symptoms and satisfaction with life. Three regressions analyses were used to investigate the relationships between self-reported socioeconomic status and depressive symptoms, adherence to traditional male norms, and gender role conflict. Results from these analyses did not support the hypotheses that socioeconomic status is related to these factors. Socioeconomic status was found to be positively correlated with satisfaction with life.
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2794976090
Cites: 79
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10